Scolaris Content Display Scolaris Content Display

Intervensi kebajikan untuk bekerja dan kesannya terhadap kesihatan mental dan fizikal ibu bapa tunggal dan

Appendices

Appendix 1. Glossary

AFDC

Aid to Families with Dependent Children (1996 changed to TANF)

AP

Anti‐Poverty

California GAIN

California Greater Avenues for Independence

CJF

Connecticut Jobs First

CR

Caseload Reduction

CWIE

Child Waiver Impact Experiments

EITC

Earned Income Tax Credit

FTP

The Family Transition Program

HCD

Human Capital Development

IFIP

Iowa Family Investment Programme

IWRE

The Indiana Welfare Reform Evaluation

JOBS

Job Opportunities and Basic Skills

LFA

Labour Force Attachment

MDRC

Manpower Demonstration Research Corporation (now MDRC)

MFIP

Minnesota Family Investment Program

MFIP‐IO

Minnesota Family Investment Program (Incentives Only)

New Hope

New Hope for families and children

NEWWS

National Evaluation of Welfare‐to‐Work Strategies

PRWORA

Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (1996)

SRDC

The Social Research and Demonstration Corporation

SSP‐A

The Self‐Sufficiency Project for Applicants

SSP‐R

The Self‐Sufficiency Project for Recipients

TANF

Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (previously AFDC)

Appendix 2. Search strategy for all databases searched

1. Medline Ovid MEDLINE(R) 1946 to March Week 4 2016 15.4.16

1. (never married adj2 (mother* or father* or parent*)).ab,ti.

2. (separated adj2 (mother* or father* or parent*)).ab,ti.

3. exp Single parent/

4. exp Single‐parent‐family/

5. fatherless famil*.ab,ti.

6. fragile famil*.ab,ti.

7. lone father*.ab,ti.

8. Lone mother*.ab,ti.

9. Lone parent*.ab,ti.

10. motherless famil*.ab,ti.

11. One parent*.ab,ti.

12. single father*.ab,ti.

13. Single mother*.ab,ti.

14. Single‐parent*.ab,ti.

15. sole father*.ab,ti.

16. sole mother*.ab,ti.

17. Sole parent*.ab,ti.

18. sole registrant*.ab,ti.

19. unmarried father*.ab,ti.

20. unmarried mother*.ab,ti.

21. unwed father*.ab,ti.

22. Unwed Mother*.ab,ti.

23. 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5 or 6 or 7 or 8 or 9 or 10 or 11 or 12 or 13 or 14 or 15 or 16 or 17 or 18 or 19 or 20 or 21 or 22

24."Canada Health and Social Transfer".ab,ti.

25."Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act".ab,ti.

26."Active labo?r market polic*".ab,ti.

27."Active labo?r market program* ".ab,ti.

28. ADFC.ab,ti.

29. "Agenda 2010".ab,ti.

30. "Aid to Families with Dependent Children".ab,ti.

31. "Allocation Parent Isole".ab,ti.

32. "ALMP".ab,ti.

33. "America Works".ab,ti.

34. (API and (work* or job* or employ* or train* or vocation*)).ab,ti.

35. "Back‐to‐work".ab,ti.

36. "cash benefit*".ab,ti.

37. "cash incentive*".ab,ti.

38. "child care assistance".ab,ti.

39. "child care provision*".ab,ti.

40. "child care subsid*".ab,ti.

41. "child care support".ab,ti.

42. CHST.ab,ti.

43. Community Wage.ab,ti.

44. "Domestic Purposes Benefit".ab,ti.

45. "Employment Tax Deduction".ab,ti.

46. "earning disregard*".ab,ti.

47. employability.ab,ti.

48. Employment.ab,ti.

49. "Employment Program*".ab,ti.

50. ETD.ab,ti.

51. exp income/

52. exp Public assistance/

53. exp Social security/

54. exp Social welfare/

55. "Family Program*".ab,ti.

56. "Family Transition Program*".ab,ti.

57. "financial benefit*".ab,ti.

58. "financial incentive*".ab,ti.

59. "financial sanction*".ab,ti.

60. "Financial support".ab,ti.

61. Financial support/

62. Financing, Government/

63. FTP.ab,ti.

64. "government intervention*".ab,ti.

65. "Government program*".ab,ti.

66. Government Programs/

67. "health care provision*".ab,ti.

68. "health care subsid*".ab,ti.

69. "health insurance provision*".ab,ti.

70. "health insurance subsid*".ab,ti.

71. "Hilfe zum Arbeit".ab,ti.

72. "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt".ab,ti.

73. "human capital development".ab,ti.

74. "income benefit*".ab,ti.

75. "income incentive*".ab,ti.

76. "income supplement*".ab,ti.

77. "Income support".ab,ti.

78. "Individual Re‐integration Agreement".ab,ti.

79. IRO.ab,ti.

80. Job.ab,ti.

81. Jobbskatteavdraget.ab,ti.

82. Jobless*.ab,ti.

83. "labo?r force attachment*".ab,ti.

84. "labo?r force participation".ab,ti.

85. "Labo?r market activation".ab,ti.

86. "mandatory employment".ab,ti.

87. MFIP.ab,ti.

88. "Minnesota Family Investment Program".ab,ti.

89. "monetary benefit*".ab,ti.

90. "monetary incentive*".ab,ti.

91. "monetary support".ab,ti.

92. ((childcare or child care) adj allowance*).ab,ti.

93. "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies".ab,ti.

94. NDLP.ab,ti.

95. "New Deal for Lone Parents".ab,ti.

96. "New Hope Project".ab,ti.

97. "Newstart allowance".ab,ti.

98. NEWWS.ab,ti.

99. "Ontario Works".ab,ti.

100. Poverty.ab,ti.

101. PRWORA.ab,ti.

102. "public welfare reform*".ab,ti.

103. (Retrain* or Re‐train*).ab,ti.

104. RMI.ab,ti.

105. sanctions.ab,ti.

106. "Self‐Sufficiency Project".ab,ti.

107. "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion".ab,ti.

108. "Social assistance".ab,ti.

109. SSP.ab,ti.

110. TANF.ab,ti.

111. "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families".ab,ti.

112. "time limit*".ab,ti.

113.Training.ab,ti.

114. Unemployment.ab,ti.

115. Vocation*.ab,ti.

116. Welfare.ab,ti.

117. "work first strateg*".ab,ti.

118. "Work for your dole".ab,ti.

119. work*.mp.

120. "Working For Families".ab,ti.

121. "tax credit*".ab,ti.

122. 24 or 25 or 26 or 27 or 28 or 29 or 30 or 31 or 32 or 33 or 34 or 35 or 36 or 37 or 38 or 39 or 40 or 41 or 42 or 43 or 44 or 45 or 46 or 47 or 48 or 49 or 50 or 51 or 52 or 53 or 54 or 55 or 56 or 57 or 58 or 59 or 60 or 61 or 62 or 63 or 64 or 65 or 66 or 67 or 68 or 69 or 70 or 71 or 72 or 73 or 74 or 75 or 76 or 77 or 78 or 79 or 80 or 81 or 82 or 83 or 84 or 85 or 86 or 87 or 88 or 89 or 90 or 91 or 92 or 93 or 94 or 95 or 96 or 97 or 98 or 99 or 100 or 101 or 102 or 103 or 104 or 105 or 106 or 107 or 108 or 109 or 110 or 111 or 112 or 113 or 114 or 115 or 116 or 117 or 118 or 119 or 120 or 121

123. randomized controlled trial.pt.

124. controlled clinical trial.pt.

125. randomized.ab.

126. placebo.ab.

127. drug therapy.fs.

128. randomly.ab.

129. trial.ab.

130. groups.ab.

131. or/123‐130

132. exp animals/ not humans.sh.

133. 131 not 132

134. 23 and 122 and 133

2. Embase 1947‐Present, updated daily 15.4.16

1. never married adj2 (mother* or father* or parent*)).ab,ti.

2. (separated adj2 (mother* or father* or parent*)).ab,ti.

3. exp Single parent/

4. fatherless famil*.ab,ti.

5. fragile famil*.ab,ti.

6. lone father*.ab,ti.

7. Lone mother*.ab,ti.

8. Lone parent*.ab,ti.

9. motherless famil*.ab,ti.

10. One parent*.ab,ti.

11. single father*.ab,ti.

12. Single mother*.ab,ti.

13. Single‐parent*.ab,ti.

14. sole father*.ab,ti. 1

15. sole mother*.ab,ti.

16. Sole parent*.ab,ti.

17. sole registrant*.ab,ti.

18. unmarried father*.ab,ti.

19. unmarried mother*.ab,ti.

20. unwed father*.ab,ti.

21. Unwed Mother*.ab,ti.

22. 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or 5 or 6 or 7 or 8 or 9 or 10 or 11 or 12 or 13 or 14 or 15 or 16 or 17 or 18 or 19 or 20 or 21.

23. "Canada Health and Social Transfer".ab,ti.

24. "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act".ab,ti.

25. "Active labo?r market polic*".ab,ti.

26. "Active labo?r market program* ".ab,ti.

27. ADFC.ab,ti.

28. "Agenda 2010".ab,ti.

29. "Aid to Families with Dependent Children".ab,ti.

30. "Allocation Parent Isole".ab,ti.

31. "ALMP".ab,ti.

32. "America Works".ab,ti.

33. (API and (work* or job* or employ* or train* or vocation*)).ab,ti.

34. "Back‐to‐work".ab,ti.

35. "cash benefit*".ab,ti.

36. "cash incentive*".ab,ti.

37. "child care assistance".ab,ti.

38. "child care provision*".ab,ti.

39. "child care subsid*".ab,ti.

40. "child care support".ab,ti.

41. CHST.ab,ti.

42. Community Wage.ab,ti.

43. "Domestic Purposes Benefit".ab,ti.

44. "Employment Tax Deduction".ab,ti.

45. "earning disregard*".ab,ti.

46. employability.ab,ti.

47. Employment.ab,ti.

48. "Employment Program*".ab,ti.

49. ETD.ab,ti.

50. exp income/

51. exp Social security/

52. exp Social welfare/

53. "Family Program*".ab,ti.

54. "Family Transition Program*".ab,ti.

55. "financial benefit*".ab,ti. 1111

56. "financial incentive*".ab,ti.

57. "financial sanction*".ab,ti.

58. "Financial support".ab,ti.

59. Financial support/

60. Financing, Government/

61. FTP.ab,ti.

62. "government intervention*".ab,ti.

63. "Government program*".ab,ti.

64. Government Programs/

65. "health care provision*".ab,ti.

66. "health care subsid*".ab,ti.

67. "health insurance provision*".ab,ti.

68. "health insurance subsid*".ab,ti.

69. "Hilfe zum Arbeit".ab,ti.

70. "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt".ab,ti.

71. "human capital development".ab,ti.

72. "income benefit*".ab,ti.

73. "income incentive*".ab,ti.

74. "income supplement*".ab,ti.

75. "Income support".ab,ti.

76. "Individual Re‐integration Agreement".ab,ti.

77. IRO.ab,ti.

78. Job.ab,ti.

79. Jobbskatteavdraget.ab,ti.

80. Jobless*.ab,ti.

81. "labo?r force attachment*".ab,ti.

82. "labo?r force participation".ab,ti.

83. "Labo?r market activation".ab,ti.

84. "mandatory employment".ab,ti.

85. MFIP.ab,ti.

86. "Minnesota Family Investment Program".ab,ti.

87. "monetary benefit*".ab,ti.

88. "monetary incentive*".ab,ti.

89. "monetary support".ab,ti.

90. ((childcare or child care) adj allowance*).ab,ti.

91. "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies".ab,ti.

92. NDLP.ab,ti.

93. "New Deal for Lone Parents".ab,ti.

94. "New Hope Project".ab,ti.

95. "Newstart allowance".ab,ti.

96. NEWWS.ab,ti.

97. "Ontario Works".ab,ti.

98. Poverty.ab,ti.

99. PRWORA.ab,ti.

100. "public welfare reform*".ab,ti.

101. (Retrain* or Re‐train*).ab,ti.

102. RMI.ab,ti.

103. sanctions.ab,ti.

104. "Self‐Sufficiency Project".ab,ti.

105. "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion".ab,ti.

106. "Social assistance".ab,ti.

107. SSP.ab,ti.

108. TANF.ab,ti.

109. "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families".ab,ti.

110. "time limit*".ab,ti.

111. Training.ab,ti.

112. Unemployment.ab,ti.

113. Vocation*.ab,ti.

114. Welfare.ab,ti.

115. "work first strateg*".ab,ti.

116. "Work for your dole".ab,ti.

117. work*.mp.

118. "Working For Families".ab,ti.

119. "tax credit*".ab,ti.

120. exp "lowest income group"/

121. exp "social care"/

122. "Public assistance".ab,ti.

123. or/23‐122

124. Random*.ab,ti.

125. Factorial*.ab,ti.

126. Crossover*.ab,ti.

127. cross over*.ab,ti.

128. cross‐over*.ab,ti.

129 .placebo*.ab,ti.

130. (doubl* adj blind*).ab,ti.

131. (singl* adj blind*).ab,ti.

132. assign*.ab,ti.

133. allocate*.ab,ti.

134. volunteer*.ab,ti.

135 .exp crossover‐procedure/

136. exp double‐blind procedure/

137. exp randomized controlled trial/

138. exp single‐blind procedure/

139. or/124‐138

140. 22 and 123 and 139

3. Psycinfo (EBSCOhost) 15.4.16

S1. ( DE "Single Parents" OR DE "Single Fathers" OR DE "Single Mothers" ) or TX (never married n2 mother*) or TX (never married n2 father*) or TX (never married n2 parent*) or TX (separated n2 mother*) or TX (separated n2 father*) or TX (separated n2 parent*) or TI fatherless famil* or AB fatherless famil* or TI fragile famil* or AB fragile famil* or TI lone father* or AB lone father* or TI Lone mother* or AB Lone mother* or TI Lone parent* or AB Lone parent* or TI never married parent* or AB never married parent* or TI "motherless famil*" OR AB "motherless famil*" OR TI "One parent*" OR AB "One parent*" OR TI "single father*" OR AB "single father*" OR TI "Single mother*" OR AB "Single mother*" OR TI "Single‐parent*" OR AB "Single‐parent*" OR TI "sole father*" OR AB "sole father*" OR TI "sole mother*" OR AB "sole mother*" OR TI "Sole parent*" OR AB "Sole parent*" OR TI "sole registrant*" OR AB "sole registrant*" OR TI "unmarried father*" OR AB "unmarried father*" OR TI "unmarried mother*" OR AB "unmarried mother*" OR TI "unwed father*" OR AB "unwed father*" OR TI "Unwed Mother*" OR AB "Unwed Mother*")

S2. DE "Income Level" OR DE "Lower Income Level" OR DE "Middle Income Level" OR DE "Upper Income Level" OR DE "Social Security" or TI "Social security" or AB "Social security" or TI ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or AB ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or TI ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or AB ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or TI "Active labo?r market polic*" or AB "Active labo?r market polic*" or TI ADFC or AB ADFC or TI "Agenda 2010" or AB "Agenda 2010" or TI "cash benefit*" or AB "cash benefit*" or TI "cash incentive*" or AB "cash incentive*" or TI "child care assistance" or AB "child care assistance" or TI "child care provision*" or AB "child care provision*" or TI "child care subsid*" or AB "child care subsid*" or TI "child care support" or AB "child care support" or TI "child care support" or AB "child care support" or TI CHST or AB CHST or TI "Community Wage" or AB "Community Wage" or TI "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or AB "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or TI "Employment Tax Deduction" or AB "Employment Tax Deduction" or TI "earning disregard*" or AB "earning disregard*" or TI employability or AB employability or TI Employment or AB Employment or TI "Employment Program*" or AB "Employment Program*" or TI ETD or AB ETD or TI "Family Program*" or AB "Family Program*" or TI "Family Transition Program*" or AB "Family Transition Program*" or TI "financial benefit*" or AB "financial benefit*" or TI "financial incentive*" or AB "financial incentive*" or TI "financial sanction*" or AB "financial sanction*" or TI "Financial support" or AB "Financial support" or TI Financing, Government or AB Financing, Government or TI FTP or AB FTP or TI "government intervention*" or AB "government intervention*" or TI "Government program*" or AB "Government program*" or "Government Programs*" or "Government Programs*" or TI "health care provision*" or AB "health care provision*" or TI "health insurance subsid*" or AB "health insurance subsid*" or TI "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or AB "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or TI "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or AB "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or TI "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or AB "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or TI "income benefit*" or AB "income benefit*" or TI "income incentive*" or AB "income incentive*" or TI "income supplement*" or AB "income supplement*" or TI "Income support" or AB "Income support" or TI "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or AB "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or TI IRO or AB IRO or TI Job or AB Job or TI Jobbskatteavdraget or AB Jobbskatteavdraget or TI Jobless* or AB Jobless* or TI "labo?r force attachment*" or AB "labo?r force attachment*" or TI "labo?r force participation" or AB "labo?r force participation" or TI "Labo?r market activation" or AB "Labo?r market activation" or TI "mandatory employment" or AB "mandatory employment" or TI MFIP or AB MFIP or TI "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or AB "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or TI "monetary benefit*" or AB "monetary benefit*" or TI "monetary incentive*" or AB "monetary incentive*" or TI "monetary support" or AB "monetary support" or TI "childcare allowance*" or AB "childcare allowance*" or TI "child care allowance*" or AB "child care allowance*" or TI "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies" or AB "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies" or TI NDLP or AB NDLP or TI "New Deal for Lone Parents" or AB "New Deal for Lone Parents" or TI "New Hope Project" or AB "New Hope Project" or TI "Newstart allowance" or AB "Newstart allowance" or TI NEWWS or AB NEWWS or TI "Ontario Works" or AB "Ontario Works" or TI Poverty or AB Poverty or TI PRWORA or AB PRWORA or TI "public welfare reform*" or AB "public welfare reform*" or TI Retrain* or AB Retrain* or TI Re‐train* or AB Re‐train* or TI RMI or AB RMI or TI sanctions or AB sanctions or TI "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or AB "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or TI "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or AB "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or TI "Social assistance" or AB "Social assistance" or TI SSP or AB SSP or TI TANF or AB TANF or TI "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or AB "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or TI "time limit*" or AB "time limit*" or TI Training or AB Training or TI Unemployment or AB Unemployment or TI Vocation* or AB Vocation* or TI Welfare or AB Welfare or TI "work first strateg*" or AB "work first strateg*" or TI work* or AB work* or TI "Working For Families" or AB "Working For Families" or TI "tax credit*" or AB "tax credit*" Or TI "Public assistance" or TI "Social welfare" Or AB "Public assistance" or AB "Social welfare"

S3. quasi‐random* or randomi?ed controlled trial or controlled clinical trial or clinical trial or trial or random*

S4. S1 AND S2 AND S3

4. ERIC (EBSCOhost) 15.4.16

S1. SU("one parent family") OR ("fatherless family") OR TI("single parent*") OR AB("single parent*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("never married father*") OR AB("never married father*") OR TI("never married mother*") OR AB("never married mother*") OR TI("never married parent*") OR AB("never married parent*") OR TI("separated mother*") OR AB("separated mother*") OR TI("separated father*") OR AB("separated father*") OR TI("Single‐parent‐family") OR AB("Single‐parent‐family") OR TI("fatherless famil*") OR AB("fatherless famil*") OR TI("fragile famil*") OR AB("fragile famil*") OR TI("lone father*") OR AB("lone father*") OR TI("Lone mother*") OR AB("Lone mother*") OR TI("motherless famil*") OR AB("motherless famil*") OR TI("One parent*") OR AB("One parent*") OR TI("single father*") OR AB("single father*") OR TI("Single mother*") OR AB("Single mother*") OR TI("Single‐parent*") OR AB("Single‐parent*") OR TI("sole father*") OR AB("sole father*") OR TI("sole mother*") OR AB("sole mother*") OR TI("Sole parent*") OR AB("Sole parent*") OR TI("sole registrant*") OR AB("sole registrant*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("unmarried mother*") OR AB("unmarried mother*") OR TI("unwed father*") OR AB("unwed father*") OR TI("Unwed Mother*") OR AB("Unwed Mother*")

S2. SU("welfare services") OR SU(income) OR SU(" family income ") OR SU(" guaranteed income ") OR SU(salaries) OR SU(" teacher salaries ") OR SU(" merit pay ") OR SU(wages) OR SU(" minimum wage ") OR SU(" low income") OR TI("Canada Health and Social Transfer") OR AB("Canada Health and Social Transfer") OR TI("Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act") OR AB("Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act") OR TI("Active labo?r market polic*") OR AB("Active labo?r market polic*") OR TI("Active labo?r market program*") OR AB("Active labo?r market program* ") OR TI(ADFC) OR AB(ADFC) OR TI(" Agenda 2010") OR AB("Agenda 2010") OR TI("Aid to Families with Dependent Children") OR AB("Aid to Families with Dependent Children") OR TI("Allocation Parent Isole") OR AB("Allocation Parent Isole") OR TI(ALMP) OR AB(ALMP) OR TI("America Works") OR AB("America Works ") OR TI(API) OR AB(API) OR TI(" Back‐to‐work") OR AB("Back‐to‐work") OR TI("cash benefit*") OR AB("cash benefit*") OR TI("cash incentive*") OR AB("cash incentive*") OR TI("child care assistance") OR AB("child care assistance") OR TI("child care provision*") OR AB("child care provision*") OR TI("child care subsid*") OR AB("child care subsid*") OR TI("child care support") OR AB("child care support ") OR TI(CHST) OR AB(CHST) OR TI(Community Wage) OR AB("Community Wage") OR TI(" Domestic Purposes Benefit") OR AB("Domestic Purposes Benefit") OR TI("Employment Tax Deduction") OR AB("Employment Tax Deduction") OR TI("earning disregard*") OR AB("earning disregard* ") OR TI(employability) OR AB(employability) OR TI(Employment) OR AB(Employment) OR TI(" Employment Program*") OR AB("Employment Program* ") OR TI(ETD) OR AB(ETD) OR TI(income) OR AB(income) OR TI(Public assistance) OR AB(Public assistance) OR TI(Social security) OR AB(Social security) OR TI(Social welfare) OR AB(Social welfare) OR TI(" Family Program*") OR AB("Family Program*") OR TI("Family Transition Program*") OR AB("Family Transition Program*") OR TI("financial benefit*") OR AB("financial benefit*") OR TI("financial incentive*") OR AB("financial incentive*") OR TI("financial sanction*") OR AB("financial sanction*") OR TI("Financial support") OR AB("Financial support ") OR TI(Financial support) OR AB(Financial support) OR TI(Financing, Government) OR AB(Financing, Government) OR TI(FTP) OR AB(FTP) OR TI(" government intervention*") OR AB("government intervention*") OR TI("Government program*") OR AB("Government program* ") OR TI(Government Programs) OR AB(Government Programs) OR TI(" health care provision*") OR AB("health care provision*") OR TI("health care subsid*") OR AB("health care subsid*") OR TI("health insurance provision*") OR AB("health insurance provision*") OR TI("health insurance subsid*") OR AB("health insurance subsid*") OR TI("Hilfe zum Arbeit") OR AB("Hilfe zum Arbeit") OR TI("Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt") OR AB("Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt") OR TI("human capital development") OR AB("human capital development") OR TI("income benefit*") OR AB("income benefit*") OR TI("income incentive*") OR AB("income incentive*") OR TI("income supplement*") OR AB("income supplement*") OR TI("Income support") OR AB("Income support") OR TI("Individual Re‐integration Agreement") OR AB("Individual Re‐integration Agreement ") OR TI(IRO) OR AB(IRO) OR TI(Job) OR AB(Job) OR TI(Jobbskatteavdraget) OR AB(Jobbskatteavdraget) OR TI(Jobless*) OR AB(Jobless*) OR TI(" labo?r force attachment*") OR AB("labo?r force attachment*") OR TI("labo?r force participation") OR AB("labo?r force participation") OR TI("Labo?r market activation") OR AB("Labo?r market activation") OR TI("mandatory employment") OR AB("mandatory employment ") OR TI(MFIP) OR AB(MFIP) OR TI(" Minnesota Family Investment Program") OR AB("Minnesota Family Investment Program") OR TI("monetary benefit*") OR AB("monetary benefit*") OR TI("monetary incentive*") OR AB("monetary incentive*") OR TI("monetary support") OR AB("monetary support") OR TI("childcare allowance*") OR AB("childcare allowance*") OR TI("child care allowance*") OR AB("child care allowance*") OR AB("National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies") OR AB("National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies") OR TI(NDLP) OR AB(NDLP) OR TI("New Deal for Lone Parents") OR AB("New Deal for Lone Parents") OR TI("New Hope Project") OR AB("New Hope Project") OR TI("Newstart allowance") OR AB("Newstart allowance") OR TI(NEWWS) OR AB(NEWWS) OR TI("Ontario Works") OR AB("Ontario Works") OR TI(Poverty) OR AB(Poverty) OR TI(PRWORA) OR AB(PRWORA) OR TI("public welfare reform*") OR AB("public welfare reform*") OR TI(Retrain*) OR TI(Re‐train*) OR AB(Retrain*) OR AB(Re‐train*) OR TI(RMI) OR AB(RMI) OR TI(sanctions) OR AB(sanctions) OR TI("Self‐Sufficiency Project") OR AB("Self‐Sufficiency Project") OR TI("Revenu Minimum d'Insertion") OR AB("Revenu Minimum d'Insertion") OR TI("Social assistance") OR AB("Social assistance") OR TI(SSP) OR AB(SSP) OR TI(TANF) OR AB(TANF) OR TI("Temporary Assistance for Needy Families") OR AB("Temporary Assistance for Needy Families") OR TI("time limit*") OR AB("time limit*") OR TI(Training) OR AB(Training) OR TI(Unemployment) OR AB(Unemployment) OR TI(Vocation*) OR AB(Vocation*) OR TI(Welfare) OR AB(Welfare) OR TI("work first strateg*") OR AB("work first strateg*") OR TI("Work for your dole") OR AB("Work for your dole") OR TI(work*) OR AB(work*) OR TI("Working For Families") OR AB("Working For Families") OR TI("tax credit*") OR AB("tax credit*")

S3. TI("quasi‐random*") OR TI("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR TI("controlled clinical trial") OR AB("quasi‐random*") OR AB("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR AB("controlled clinical trial") OR TI("clinical trial") OR TI(trial) OR TI(random*) OR AB("clinical trial") OR AB(trial) OR AB(random*)

S4. S1 AND S2 AND S3

5. Socindex (EBSCOhost) 15.4.16

S1. ((DE "PUBLIC welfare" OR DE "ALMSHOUSES" OR DE "ASYLUMS" OR DE "CHILD welfare" OR DE "COMMUNITY organization" OR DE "FAITH‐based initiative (Government program)" OR DE "FOOD stamps" OR DE "FRESH‐air charity" OR DE "INCOME maintenance programs" OR DE "INSTITUTIONAL care" OR DE "LEGAL assistance to the poor" OR DE "MATERNALISM (Public welfare)" OR DE "MILITARY social work" OR DE "NATIONAL service" OR DE "SOCIAL medicine" OR DE "SOCIAL service, Rural" OR DE "TRANSIENTS, Relief of" OR DE "WELFARE fraud" OR DE "WELFARE state") OR (DE "SOCIAL security" OR DE "WORKERS' compensation")) OR (DE "FAMILY policy" OR DE "CHILD welfare") or TI "Social security" or AB "Social security" or TI ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or AB ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or TI ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or AB ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or TI "Active labo?r market polic*" or AB "Active labo?r market polic*" or TI ADFC or AB ADFC or TI "Agenda 2010" or AB "Agenda 2010" or TI "cash benefit*" or AB "cash benefit*" or TI "cash incentive*" or AB "cash incentive*" or TI "child care assistance" or AB "child care assistance" or TI "child care provision*" or AB "child care provision*" or TI "child care subsid*" or AB "child care subsid*" or TI "child care support" or AB "child care support" or TI "child care support" or AB "child care support" or TI CHST or AB CHST or TI "Community Wage" or AB "Community Wage" or TI "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or AB "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or TI "Employment Tax Deduction" or AB "Employment Tax Deduction" or TI "earning disregard*" or AB "earning disregard*" or TI employability or AB employability or TI Employment or AB Employment or TI "Employment Program*" or AB "Employment Program*" or TI ETD or AB ETD or TI "Family Program*" or AB "Family Program*" or TI "Family Transition Program*" or AB "Family Transition Program*" or TI "financial benefit*" or AB "financial benefit*" or TI "financial incentive*" or AB "financial incentive*" or TI "financial sanction*" or AB "financial sanction*" or TI "Financial support" or AB "Financial support" or TI Financing, Government or AB Financing, Government or TI FTP or AB FTP or TI "government intervention*" or AB "government intervention*" or TI "Government program*" or AB "Government program*" or "Government Programs*" or "Government Programs*" or TI "health care provision*" or AB "health care provision*" or TI "health insurance subsid*" or AB "health insurance subsid*" or TI "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or AB "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or TI "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or AB "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or TI "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or AB "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or TI "income benefit*" or AB "income benefit*" or TI "income incentive*" or AB "income incentive*" or TI "income supplement*" or AB "income supplement*" or TI "Income support" or AB "Income support" or TI "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or AB "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or TI IRO or AB IRO or TI Job or AB Job or TI Jobbskatteavdraget or AB Jobbskatteavdraget or TI Jobless* or AB Jobless* or TI "labo?r force attachment*" or AB "labo?r force attachment*" or TI "labo?r force participation" or AB "labo?r force participation" or TI "Labo?r market activation" or AB "Labo?r market activation" or TI "mandatory employment" or AB "mandatory employment" or TI MFIP or AB MFIP or TI "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or AB "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or TI "monetary benefit*" or AB "monetary benefit*" or TI "monetary incentive*" or AB "monetary incentive*" or TI "monetary support" or AB "monetary support" or TI "childcare allowance*" or AB "childcare allowance*" or TI "child care allowance*" or AB "child care allowance*" or TI "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies" or AB "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies" or TI NDLP or AB NDLP or TI "New Deal for Lone Parents" or AB "New Deal for Lone Parents" or TI "New Hope Project" or AB "New Hope Project" or TI "Newstart allowance" or AB "Newstart allowance" or TI NEWWS or AB NEWWS or TI "Ontario Works" or AB "Ontario Works" or TI Poverty or AB Poverty or TI PRWORA or AB PRWORA or TI "public welfare reform*" or AB "public welfare reform*" or TI Retrain* or AB Retrain* or TI Re‐train* or AB Re‐train* or TI RMI or AB RMI or TI sanctions or AB sanctions or TI "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or AB "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or TI "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or AB "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or TI "Social assistance" or AB "Social assistance" or TI SSP or AB SSP or TI TANF or AB TANF or TI "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or AB "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or TI "time limit*" or AB "time limit*" or TI Training or AB Training or TI Unemployment or AB Unemployment or TI Vocation* or AB Vocation* or TI Welfare or AB Welfare or TI "work first strateg*" or AB "work first strateg*" or TI work* or AB work* or TI "Working For Families" or AB "Working For Families" or TI "tax credit*" or AB "tax credit*" Or TI "Public assistance" or TI "Social welfare" Or AB "Public assistance" or AB "Social welfare"

S2. TX (never married n2 mother*) or TX (never married n2 father*) or TX (never married n2 parent*) or TX (separated n2 mother*) or TX (separated n2 father*) or TX (separated n2 parent*) or TI fatherless famil* or AB fatherless famil* or TI fragile famil* or AB fragile famil* or TI lone father* or AB lone father* or TI Lone mother* or AB Lone mother* or TI Lone parent* or AB Lone parent* or TI never married parent* or AB never married parent* or TI "motherless famil*" OR AB "motherless famil*" OR TI "One parent*" OR AB "One parent*" OR TI "single father*" OR AB "single father*" OR TI "Single mother*" OR AB "Single mother*" OR TI "Single‐parent*" OR AB "Single‐parent*" OR TI "sole father*" OR AB "sole father*" OR TI "sole mother*" OR AB "sole mother*" OR TI "Sole parent*" OR AB "Sole parent*" OR TI "sole registrant*" OR AB "sole registrant*" OR TI "unmarried father*" OR AB "unmarried father*" OR TI "unmarried mother*" OR AB "unmarried mother*" OR TI "unwed father*" OR AB "unwed father*" OR TI "Unwed Mother*" OR AB "Unwed Mother*"

S3. quasi‐random* or randomi?ed controlled trial or controlled clinical trial or clinical trial or trial or random*

S4. S1 AND S2 AND S3

6. CINAHL (EBSCOhost) 15.4.16

S1. (MH "Income") or (MH "Public Assistance+") or (MH "Social Welfare+") or TI "Social security" or AB "Social security" or TI ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or AB ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or TI ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or AB ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or TI "Active labo?r market polic*" or AB "Active labo?r market polic*" or TI ADFC or AB ADFC or TI "Agenda 2010" or AB "Agenda 2010" or TI "Social security" or AB "Social security" or TI ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or AB ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or TI ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or AB ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or TI "Active labo?r market polic*" or AB "Active labo?r market polic*" or TI ADFC or AB ADFC or TI "Agenda 2010" or AB "Agenda 2010" or TI "cash benefit*" or AB "cash benefit*" or TI "cash incentive*" or AB "cash incentive*" or TI "child care assistance" or AB "child care assistance" or TI "child care provision*" or AB "child care provision*" or TI "child care subsid*" or AB "child care subsid*" or TI "child care support" or AB "child care support" or TI "child care support" or AB "child care support" or TI CHST or AB CHST or TI "Community Wage" or AB "Community Wage" or TI "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or AB "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or TI "Employment Tax Deduction" or AB "Employment Tax Deduction" or TI "earning disregard*" or AB "earning disregard*" or TI employability or AB employability or TI Employment or AB Employment or TI "Employment Program*" or AB "Employment Program*" or TI ETD or AB ETD or TI "Family Program*" or AB "Family Program*" or TI "Family Transition Program*" or AB "Family Transition Program*" or TI "financial benefit*" or AB "financial benefit*" or TI "financial incentive*" or AB "financial incentive*" or TI "financial sanction*" or AB "financial sanction*" or TI "Financial support" or AB "Financial support" or TI Financing, Government or AB Financing, Government or TI FTP or AB FTP or TI "government intervention*" or AB "government intervention*" or TI "Government program*" or AB "Government program*" or "Government Programs*" or "Government Programs*" or TI "health care provision*" or AB "health care provision*" or TI "health insurance subsid*" or AB "health insurance subsid*" or TI "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or AB "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or TI "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or AB "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or TI "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or AB "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or TI "income benefit*" or AB "income benefit*" or TI "income incentive*" or AB "income incentive*" or TI "income supplement*" or AB "income supplement*" or TI "Income support" or AB "Income support" or TI "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or AB "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or TI IRO or AB IRO or TI Job or AB Job or TI Jobbskatteavdraget or AB Jobbskatteavdraget or TI Jobless* or AB Jobless* or TI "labo?r force attachment*" or AB "labo?r force attachment*" or TI "labo?r force participation" or AB "labo?r force participation" or TI "Labo?r market activation" or AB "Labo?r market activation" or TI "mandatory employment" or AB "mandatory employment" or TI MFIP or AB MFIP or TI "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or AB "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or TI "monetary benefit*" or AB "monetary benefit*" or TI "monetary incentive*" or AB "monetary incentive*" or TI "monetary support" or AB "monetary support" or TI "childcare allowance*" or AB "childcare allowance*" or TI "child care allowance*" or AB "child care allowance*" or TI "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies" or AB "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies" or TI NDLP or AB NDLP or TI "New Deal for Lone Parents" or AB "New Deal for Lone Parents" or TI "New Hope Project" or AB "New Hope Project" or TI "Newstart allowance" or AB "Newstart allowance" or TI NEWWS or AB NEWWS or TI "Ontario Works" or AB "Ontario Works" or TI Poverty or AB Poverty or TI PRWORA or AB PRWORA or TI "public welfare reform*" or AB "public welfare reform*" or TI Retrain* or AB Retrain* or TI Re‐train* or AB Re‐train* or TI RMI or AB RMI or TI sanctions or AB sanctions or TI "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or AB "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or TI "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or AB "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or TI "Social assistance" or AB "Social assistance" or TI SSP or AB SSP or TI TANF or AB TANF or TI "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or AB "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or TI "time limit*" or AB "time limit*" or TI Training or AB Training or TI Unemployment or AB Unemployment or TI Vocation* or AB Vocation* or TI Welfare or AB Welfare or TI "work first strateg*" or AB "work first strateg*" or TI work* or AB work* or TI "Working For Families" or AB "Working For Families" or TI "tax credit*" or AB "tax credit*"

S2. TX (never married n2 mother*) or TX (never married n2 father*) or TX (never married n2 parent*) or TX (separated n2 mother*) or TX (separated n2 father*) or TX (separated n2 parent*) or TI fatherless famil* or AB fatherless famil* or TI fragile famil* or AB fragile famil* or TI lone father* or AB lone father* or TI Lone mother* or AB Lone mother* or TI Lone parent* or AB Lone parent* or TI never married parent* or AB never married parent* or TI "motherless famil*" OR AB "motherless famil*" OR TI "One parent*" OR AB "One parent*" OR TI "single father*" OR AB "single father*" OR TI "Single mother*" OR AB "Single mother*" OR TI "Single‐parent*" OR AB "Single‐parent*" OR TI "sole father*" OR AB "sole father*" OR TI "sole mother*" OR AB "sole mother*" OR TI "Sole parent*" OR AB "Sole parent*" OR TI "sole registrant*" OR AB "sole registrant*" OR TI "unmarried father*" OR AB "unmarried father*" OR TI "unmarried mother*" OR AB "unmarried mother*" OR TI "unwed father*" OR AB "unwed father*" OR TI "Unwed Mother*" OR AB "Unwed Mother*"

S3. MH "Quantitative Studies" or MH "Clinical Trials+" or MH "Placebos" or MH "randomisation" or TX allocat* random* or TX placebo* or TX random* allocat* or TX randomi* control* trial* or TX (singl* n1 blind*) or TX (singl* n1 mask*) or TX (doubl* n1 blind*) or TX (doubl* n1 mask*) or TX (tripl* n1 blind*) or TX (tripl* n1 mask*) or TX (trebl* n1 blind*) or TX (trebl* n1 mask*)

S4. S1 AND S2 AND S3

7. Econlit (EBSCOhost) 15.4.16

S1. (ZU "social security") or (ZU "social security and public pensions") or (ZU "welfare and poverty: general") or (ZU "welfare and poverty: government programs; provision and effects of welfare programs") or (ZU "welfare and poverty: other") or (ZU "welfare economics: general") or TI "Social security" or AB "Social security" or TI ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or AB ( "Canada Health and Social Transfer" ) or TI ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or AB ( "Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" ) or TI "Active labo?r market polic*" or AB "Active labo?r market polic*" or TI ADFC or AB ADFC or TI "Agenda 2010" or AB "Agenda 2010" or TI "cash benefit*" or AB "cash benefit*" or TI "cash incentive*" or AB "cash incentive*" or TI "child care assistance" or AB "child care assistance" or TI "child care provision*" or AB "child care provision*" or TI "child care subsid*" or AB "child care subsid*" or TI "child care support" or AB "child care support" or TI "child care support" or AB "child care support" or TI CHST or AB CHST or TI "Community Wage" or AB "Community Wage" or TI "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or AB "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or TI "Employment Tax Deduction" or AB "Employment Tax Deduction" or TI "earning disregard*" or AB "earning disregard*" or TI employability or AB employability or TI Employment or AB Employment or TI "Employment Program*" or AB "Employment Program*" or TI ETD or AB ETD or TI "Family Program*" or AB "Family Program*" or TI "Family Transition Program*" or AB "Family Transition Program*" or TI "financial benefit*" or AB "financial benefit*" or TI "financial incentive*" or AB "financial incentive*" or TI "financial sanction*" or AB "financial sanction*" or TI "Financial support" or AB "Financial support" or TI Financing, Government or AB Financing, Government or TI FTP or AB FTP or TI "government intervention*" or AB "government intervention*" or TI "Government program*" or AB "Government program*" or "Government Programs*" or "Government Programs*" or TI "health care provision*" or AB "health care provision*" or TI "health insurance subsid*" or AB "health insurance subsid*" or TI "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or AB "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or TI "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or AB "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or TI "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or AB "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or TI "income benefit*" or AB "income benefit*" or TI "income incentive*" or AB "income incentive*" or TI "income supplement*" or AB "income supplement*" or TI "Income support" or AB "Income support" or TI "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or AB "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or TI IRO or AB IRO or TI Job or AB Job or TI Jobbskatteavdraget or AB Jobbskatteavdraget or TI Jobless* or AB Jobless* or TI "labo?r force attachment*" or AB "labo?r force attachment*" or TI "labo?r force participation" or AB "labo?r force participation" or TI "Labo?r market activation" or AB "Labo?r market activation" or TI "mandatory employment" or AB "mandatory employment" or TI MFIP or AB MFIP or TI "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or AB "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or TI "monetary benefit*" or AB "monetary benefit*" or TI "monetary incentive*" or AB "monetary incentive*" or TI "monetary support" or AB "monetary support" or TI "childcare allowance*" or AB "childcare allowance*" or TI "child care allowance*" or AB "child care allowance*" or TI "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies" or AB "National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work Strategies" or TI NDLP or AB NDLP or TI "New Deal for Lone Parents" or AB "New Deal for Lone Parents" or TI "New Hope Project" or AB "New Hope Project" or TI "Newstart allowance" or AB "Newstart allowance" or TI NEWWS or AB NEWWS or TI "Ontario Works" or AB "Ontario Works" or TI Poverty or AB Poverty or TI PRWORA or AB PRWORA or TI "public welfare reform*" or AB "public welfare reform*" or TI Retrain* or AB Retrain* or TI Re‐train* or AB Re‐train* or TI RMI or AB RMI or TI sanctions or AB sanctions or TI "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or AB "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or TI "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or AB "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or TI "Social assistance" or AB "Social assistance" or TI SSP or AB SSP or TI TANF or AB TANF or TI "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or AB "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or TI "time limit*" or AB "time limit*" or TI Training or AB Training or TI Unemployment or AB Unemployment or TI Vocation* or AB Vocation* or TI Welfare or AB Welfare or TI "work first strateg*" or AB "work first strateg*" or TI work* or AB work* or TI "Working For Families" or AB "Working For Families" or TI "tax credit*" or AB "tax credit*" Or TI "Public assistance" or TI "Social welfare" Or AB "Public assistance" or AB "Social welfare" or TI income or AB income

S2. TX (never married n2 mother*) or TX (never married n2 father*) or TX (never married n2 parent*) or TX (separated n2 mother*) or TX (separated n2 father*) or TX (separated n2 parent*) or TI fatherless famil* or AB fatherless famil* or TI fragile famil* or AB fragile famil* or TI lone father* or AB lone father* or TI Lone mother* or AB Lone mother* or TI Lone parent* or AB Lone parent* or TI never married parent* or AB never married parent* or TI "motherless famil*" OR AB "motherless famil*" OR TI "One parent*" OR AB "One parent*" OR TI "single father*" OR AB "single father*" OR TI "Single mother*" OR AB "Single mother*" OR TI "Single‐parent*" OR AB "Single‐parent*" OR TI "sole father*" OR AB "sole father*" OR TI "sole mother*" OR AB "sole mother*" OR TI "Sole parent*" OR AB "Sole parent*" OR TI "sole registrant*" OR AB "sole registrant*" OR TI "unmarried father*" OR AB "unmarried father*" OR TI "unmarried mother*" OR AB "unmarried mother*" OR TI "unwed father*" OR AB "unwed father*" OR TI "Unwed Mother*" OR AB "Unwed Mother*"

S3. quasi‐random* or randomi?ed controlled trial or controlled clinical trial or clinical trial or trial or random*

S4. S1 AND S2 AND S3

8. The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) 15.4.16

#1. ("single parent*" or "unmarried father*" or "never married father*" or "never married mother*" or "never married parent*" or "separated mother*" or "separated father*" or "Single‐parent‐family" or "fatherless famil*" or "fragile famil*" or "lone father*" or "Lone mother*" or "lone parent" or "motherless famil*" or "One parent*"or "single father*" or "Single mother*"or "Single‐parent*" or "sole father*" or "sole mother*" or "Sole parent*" or "sole registrant*" or "unmarried father*" or "unmarried mother*" or "unwed father*" or "Unwed Mother*"):ti,ab,kw

#2. (income or "Public assistance" or "Social security" or "Social welfare" or "Canada Health Social Transfer" or "Personal Responsibility Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act" or "Active labo?r market polic*" or "Active labo?r market program*" or ADFC or "Agenda 2010" or "Aid to Families with Dependent Children" or "Allocation Parent Isole" or ALMP or "America Works" or API or "Back‐to‐work" or "cash benefit*" or "cash incentive*" or "child care assistance" or "child care provision*" or "child care subsid*" or "child care support" or CHST or "Community Wage" or "Domestic Purposes Benefit" or "Employment Tax Deduction" or "earning disregard*" or employability or Employment or "Employment Program*" or ETD or "Family Program*" or "Family Transition Program*" or "financial benefit*" or "financial incentive*" or "financial sanction*" or "Financial support" or "Government Financing" or FTP or "government intervention*" or "Government program*" or "Government Programs" or "health care provision*" or "health care subsid*" or "health insurance provision*" or "health insurance subsid*" or "Hilfe zum Arbeit" or "Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt" or "human capital development" or "income benefit*" or "income incentive*" or "income supplement*" or "Income support" or "Individual Re‐integration Agreement" or IRO or Job or Jobbskatteavdraget or Jobless* or "labo?r force attachment*" or "labo?r force participation" or "Labo?r market activation" or "mandatory employment" or MFIP or "Minnesota Family Investment Program" or "monetary benefit*" or "monetary incentive*" or "monetary support" or "childcare allowance*" or "child care allowance*" or "National Evaluation of Welfare to work Strategies" or NDLP or "New Deal for Lone Parents" or "New Hope Project" or "Newstart allowance" or NEWWS or "Ontario Works" or Poverty or PRWORA or "public welfare reform*" or Retrain* or Re‐train* or RMI or sanctions or "Self‐Sufficiency Project" or "Revenu Minimum d'Insertion" or "Social assistance" or SSP or TANF or "Temporary Assistance for Needy Families" or "time limit*" or Training or Unemployment or Vocation* or Welfare or "work first strateg*"or "Work for your dole" or work*or "Working For Families" or "tax credit*") :ti,ab,kw

#3. #1 and #2

9. Web of Science (all databases) 15.4.16

TOPIC: (income or welfare or work* or train* or Social security or Public assistance or financ* or allowance or polic* or Retrain* or Back‐to‐work or employability or Employment or job or poverty or sanctions) AND TOPIC: (single parent* or unmarried father* or never married father* or never married mother* or never married parent* or separated mother* or separated father* or Single‐parent‐family or fatherless famil* or fragile famil* or lone father* or Lone mother* or motherless famil* or One parent* or single father* or Single mother* or Single‐parent* or sole father* or sole mother* or Sole parent* or sole registrant* or unmarried father* or unmarried mother* or unwed father* or Unwed Mother*) AND TOPIC: (quasi‐random* or randomi?ed controlled trial or controlled clinical trial or quasi‐random* or randomi?ed controlled trial or controlled clinical trial or clinical trial or trial or random*)

10. Applied Social Sciences Index and Abstracts (ASSIA) (Proquest) 16.4.16

((SU(income) OR SU("social welfare") OR SU("economic welfare") OR SU("red cross") OR SU("social security") OR SU("attendance allowances") OR SU("child benefit") OR SU("disability allowances") OR SU("disability living allowance") OR SU("domestic assistance allowances") OR SU("energy allowances") OR SU("familyy allowances") OR SU("familyy credit") OR SU("furniture allowances") OR SU("housing benefits") OR SU("housing grants") OR SU("incapacity benefit") OR SU("independent living fund") OR SU("industrial injury benefits") OR SU("invalidity benefit") OR SU("maternity benefits") OR SU(medicaid) OR SU(medicare) OR SU("mobility allowances") OR SU("national provident funds") OR SU("severe weather payments") OR SU("sickness benefits") OR SU("social fund") OR SU("emergency social funds") OR TI("Canada Health and Social Transfer") OR AB("Canada Health and Social Transfer") OR TI("Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act") OR AB("Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act") OR TI("Active labo?r market polic*") OR AB("Active labo?r market polic*") OR TI("Active labo?r market program*") OR AB("Active labo?r market program*") OR TI(ADFC) OR AB(ADFC) OR TI("Agenda 2010") OR AB("Agenda 2010") OR TI("Aid to Families with Dependent Children") OR AB("Aid to Families with Dependent Children") OR TI("Allocation Parent Isole") OR AB("Allocation Parent Isole") OR TI(ALMP) OR AB(ALMP) OR TI("America Works") OR AB("America Works") OR TI(API) OR AB(API) OR TI("Back‐to‐work") OR AB("Back‐to‐work") OR TI("cash benefit*") OR AB("cash benefit*") OR TI("cash incentive*") OR AB("cash incentive*") OR TI("child care assistance") OR AB("child care assistance") OR TI("child care provision*") OR AB("child care provision*") OR TI("child care subsidy*") OR AB("child care subsidy*") OR TI("child care support") OR AB("child care support") OR TI(chest) OR AB(chest) OR TI("Community Wage") OR AB("Community Wage") OR TI("Domestic Purposes Benefit") OR AB("Domestic Purposes Benefit") OR TI("Employment Tax Deduction") OR AB("Employment Tax Deduction") OR TI("earning disregard*") OR AB("earning disregard*") OR TI(employability) OR AB(employability) OR TI(Employment) OR AB(Employment) OR TI("Employment Program*") OR AB("Employment Program*") OR TI(ETD) OR AB(ETD) OR TI(income) OR AB(income) OR TI("Public assistance") OR AB("Public assistance") OR TI("Social security") OR AB("Social security") OR TI("Social welfare") OR AB("Social welfare") OR TI("familyy Program*") OR AB("familyy Program*") OR TI("familyy Transition Program*") OR AB("familyy Transition Program*") OR TI("financial benefit*") OR AB("financial benefit*") OR TI("financial incentive*") OR AB("financial incentive*") OR TI("financial sanction*") OR AB("financial sanction*") OR TI("Financial support") OR AB("Financial support") OR TI("Financial support") OR AB("Financial support") OR TI("Financing, Government") OR AB("Financing, Government") OR TI(FTP) OR AB(FTP) OR TI("government intervention*") OR AB("government intervention*") OR TI("Government program*") OR AB("Government program*") OR TI("Government Programs") OR AB("Government Programs") OR TI("health care provision*") OR AB("health care provision*") OR TI("health care subsidy*") OR AB("health care subsidy*") OR TI("health insurance provision*") OR AB("health insurance provision*") OR TI("health insurance subsidy*") OR AB("health insurance subsidy*") OR TI("Hilfe zum Arbeit") OR AB("Hilfe zum Arbeit") OR TI("Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt") OR AB("Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt") OR TI("human capital development") OR AB("human capital development") OR TI("income benefit*") OR AB("income benefit*") OR TI("income incentive*") OR AB("income incentive*") OR TI("income supplement*") OR AB("income supplement*") OR TI("Income support") OR AB("Income support") OR TI("Individual Re‐integration Agreement") OR AB("Individual Re‐integration Agreement") OR TI(IRO) OR AB(IRO) OR TI(Job) OR AB(Job) OR TI(Jobbskatteavdraget) OR AB(Jobbskatteavdraget) OR TI(Jobless*) OR AB(Jobless*) OR TI("labo?r force attachment*") OR AB("labo?r force attachment*") OR TI("labo?r force participation") OR AB("labo?r force participation") OR TI("Labo?r market activation") OR AB("Labo?r market activation") OR TI("mandatory employment") OR AB("mandatory employment") OR TI(MFIP) OR AB(MFIP) OR TI("Minnesota familyy Investment Program") OR AB("Minnesota familyy Investment Program") OR TI("monetary benefit*") OR AB("monetary benefit*") OR TI("monetary incentive*") OR AB("monetary incentive*") OR TI("monetary support") OR AB("monetary support") OR TI("childcare allowance*") OR AB("childcare allowance*") OR TI("child care allowance*") OR AB("child care allowance*") OR AB("National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work strategyies") OR AB("National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work strategyies") OR TI(NDLP) OR AB(NDLP) OR TI("New Deal for Lone Parents") OR AB("New Deal for Lone Parents") OR TI("New Hope Project") OR AB("New Hope Project") OR TI("Newstart allowance") OR AB("Newstart allowance") OR TI(news) OR AB(news) OR TI("Ontario Works") OR AB("Ontario Works") OR TI(Poverty) OR AB(Poverty) OR TI(PRWORA) OR AB(PRWORA) OR TI("public welfare reform*") OR AB("public welfare reform*") OR TI(Retrain*) OR TI(restrain*) OR AB(Retrain*) OR AB(restrain*) OR TI(RMI) OR AB(RMI) OR TI(sanctions) OR AB(sanctions) OR TI("Self‐Sufficiency Project") OR AB("Self‐Sufficiency Project") OR TI("Revenu Minimum d'Insertion") OR AB("Revenu Minimum d'Insertion") OR TI("Social assistance") OR AB("Social assistance") OR TI(SSP) OR AB(SSP) OR TI(TANF) OR AB(TANF) OR TI("Temporary Assistance for Needy Families ") OR AB("Temporary Assistance for Needy Families ") OR TI("time limit*") OR AB("time limit*") OR TI(Training) OR AB(Training) OR TI(Unemployment) OR AB(Unemployment) OR TI(Vocation*) OR AB(Vocation*) OR TI(Welfare) OR AB(Welfare) OR TI("work first strategy*") OR AB("work first strategy*") OR TI("Work for your dole") OR AB("Work for your dole") OR TI(work*) OR AB(work*) OR TI("Working For Families ") OR AB("Working For Families ") OR TI("tax credit*") OR AB("tax credit*")) AND (SU("single parent Families ") OR SU("single mothers") OR SU("low income single mothers") OR SU("single adolescent mothers") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("never married father*") OR AB("never married father*") OR TI("never married mother*") OR AB("never married mother*") OR TI("never married parent*") OR AB("never married parent*") OR TI("separated mother*") OR AB("separated mother*") OR TI("separated father*") OR AB("separated father*") OR TI("Single‐parent‐familyy") OR AB("Single‐parent‐familyy") OR TI("fatherless family*") OR AB("fatherless family*") OR TI("fragile family*") OR AB("fragile family*") OR TI("lone father*") OR AB("lone father*") OR TI("Lone mother*") OR AB("Lone mother*") OR TI("motherless family*") OR AB("motherless family*") OR TI("One parent*") OR AB("One parent*") OR TI("single father*") OR AB("single father*") OR TI("Single mother*") OR AB("Single mother*") OR TI("Single‐parent*") OR AB("Single‐parent*") OR TI("sole father*") OR AB("sole father*") OR TI("sole mother*") OR AB("sole mother*") OR TI("Sole parent*") OR AB("Sole parent*") OR TI("sole registrant*") OR AB("sole registrant*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("unmarried mother*") OR AB("unmarried mother*") OR TI("unwed father*") OR AB("unwed father*") OR TI("Unwed Mother*") OR AB("Unwed Mother*")) AND (TI("quasi‐random*") OR TI("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR TI("controlled clinical trial") OR AB("quasi‐random*") OR AB("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR AB("controlled clinical trial") OR TI("clinical trial") OR TI(trial) OR TI(random*) OR AB("clinical trial") OR AB(trial) OR AB(random*))) AND (SU("single parent Families ") OR SU("single mothers") OR SU("low income single mothers") OR SU("single adolescent mothers") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("never married father*") OR AB("never married father*") OR TI("never married mother*") OR AB("never married mother*") OR TI("never married parent*") OR AB("never married parent*") OR TI("separated mother*") OR AB("separated mother*") OR TI("separated father*") OR AB("separated father*") OR TI("Single‐parent‐familyy") OR AB("Single‐parent‐familyy") OR TI("fatherless family*") OR AB("fatherless family*") OR TI("fragile family*") OR AB("fragile family*") OR TI("lone father*") OR AB("lone father*") OR TI("Lone mother*") OR AB("Lone mother*") OR TI("motherless family*") OR AB("motherless family*") OR TI("One parent*") OR AB("One parent*") OR TI("single father*") OR AB("single father*") OR TI("Single mother*") OR AB("Single mother*") OR TI("Single‐parent*") OR AB("Single‐parent*") OR TI("sole father*") OR AB("sole father*") OR TI("sole mother*") OR AB("sole mother*") OR TI("Sole parent*") OR AB("Sole parent*") OR TI("sole registrant*") OR AB("sole registrant*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("unmarried mother*") OR AB("unmarried mother*") OR TI("unwed father*") OR AB("unwed father*") OR TI("Unwed Mother*") OR AB("Unwed Mother*")) AND (TI("quasi‐random*") OR TI("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR TI("controlled clinical trial") OR AB("quasi‐random*") OR AB("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR AB("controlled clinical trial") OR TI("clinical trial") OR TI(trial) OR TI(random*) OR AB("clinical trial") OR AB(trial) OR AB(random*))

Limits: Peer reviewed

11. International Bibliography of the Social Sciences (IBSS) (ProQuest) 16.4.16

(SU(income) OR SU("agricultural income") OR SU(" disposable income") OR SU("familyy income") OR SU(" farm income") OR SU("farmers income") OR SU(" household income") OR SU("income elasticity") OR SU(" industrial income") OR SU("low income") OR SU(" minimum income") OR SU("guaranteed minimum income") OR SU(" national income") OR SU("public revenuee") OR SU("public property revenuee") OR SU("wages national income ratio") OR SU(" per capita income") OR SU("permanent income") OR SU(" real income") OR SU("tariff revenuees") OR SU(" tax revenuee ") OR SU(" social welfare") OR SU("community care") OR SU("social security") OR SU("familyy allowances") OR SU("health insurance") OR SU("housing allowances") OR SU("maternity benefits") OR SU("means testing") OR SU("redistributive social security") OR SU("social security financing") OR SU("social security funds") OR SU("social services") OR SU("social support") OR SU("benefit plans") OR SU("disability benefit") OR SU("disabled rehabilitation") OR SU("social workers ") OR TI("Public assistance") OR AB("Public assistance") OR TI(" Canada Health and Social Transfer") OR AB("Canada Health and Social Transfer") OR TI(" Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act") OR AB("Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act") OR TI(" Active labo?r market polic*") OR AB("Active labo?r market polic*") OR TI(" Active labo?r market program* ") OR AB("Active labo?r market program*") OR TI(ADFC) OR AB(ADFC) OR TI(" Agenda 2010") OR AB("Agenda 2010") OR TI(" Aid to Families with Dependent Children") OR AB("Aid to Families with Dependent Children") OR TI(" Allocation Parent Isole") OR AB("Allocation Parent Isole") OR TI(" ALMP") OR AB("ALMP") OR TI(" America Works") OR AB("America Works") OR TI(API) OR AB(API) OR TI(" Back‐to‐work") OR AB("Back‐to‐work") OR TI(" cash benefit*") OR AB("cash benefit*") OR TI(" cash incentive*") OR AB("cash incentive*") OR TI("child care assistance") OR AB("child care assistance") OR TI("child care provision*") OR AB("child care provision*") OR TI("child care subsidy*") OR AB("child care subsidy*") OR TI("child care support") OR AB("child care support") OR TI(chest) OR AB(chest) OR TI("Community Wage") OR AB("Community Wage") OR TI("Domestic Purposes Benefit") OR AB(" Domestic Purposes Benefit") OR TI("Employment Tax Deduction") OR AB(" Employment Tax Deduction") OR TI("earning disregard*") OR AB("earning disregard*") OR TI(employability) OR AB(employability) OR TI(Employment) OR AB(Employment) OR TI("Employment Program*") OR AB(" Employment Program*") OR TI(ETD) OR AB(ETD) OR TI(income) OR AB(income) OR TI("Public assistance") OR AB("Public assistance") OR TI("Social security") OR AB("Social security") OR TI(Social welfare ") Or AB(" Social welfare ") Or TI(" familyy Program* ") or AB(" familyy Program* ") or TI(" familyy Transition Program* ") or AB(" familyy Transition Program* ") or TI(" financial benefit* ") or AB(" financial benefit* ") or TI(" financial incentive* ") or AB(" financial incentive* ") or TI(" financial sanction* ") or AB(" financial sanction* ") or TI(" Financial support ") or AB(" Financial support ") or TI(" Financial support ") Or AB(" Financial support ") Or TI(" Financing, Government ") Or AB(" Financing, Government ") Or TI(FTP) Or AB(FTP) Or TI(" government intervention* ") or AB(" government intervention* ") or TI(" Government program* ") or AB(" Government program* ") or TI(" Government Programs ") Or AB(" Government Programs ") Or TI(" health care provision* ") or AB(" health care provision* ") or TI(" health care subsidy* ") or AB(" health care subsidy* ") or TI(" health insurance provision* ") or AB(" health insurance provision* ") or TI(" health insurance subsidy* ") or AB(" health insurance subsidy* ") or TI(" Hilfe zum albeit ") or AB(" Hilfe zum albeit ") or TI(" Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt ") or AB(" Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt ") or TI(" human capital development ") or AB(" human capital development ") or TI(" income benefit* ") or AB(" income benefit* ") or TI(" income incentive* ") or AB(" income incentive* ") or TI(" income supplement* ") or AB(" income supplement* ") or TI(" Income support ") or AB(" Income support ") or TI(" Individual reintegration Agreement ") or AB(" Individual reintegration Agreement ") or TI(IRO) Or AB(IRO) Or TI(Job) Or AB(Job) Or TI(Jobbskatteavdraget) Or AB(Jobbskatteavdraget) Or TI(Jobless*) Or AB(Jobless*) Or TI(" labo?r force attachment* ") or AB(" labo?r force attachment* ") or TI(" labo?r force participation ") or AB(" labo?r force participation ") or TI(" Labo?r market activation ") or AB(" Labo?r market activation ") or TI(" mandatory employment ") or AB(" mandatory employment ") or TI(MFIP) Or AB(MFIP) Or TI(" Minnesota familyy Investment Program ") or AB(" Minnesota familyy Investment Program ") or TI(" monetary benefit* ") or AB(" monetary benefit* ") or TI(" monetary incentive* ") or AB(" monetary incentive* ") or TI(" monetary support ") or AB(" monetary support ") or TI(" childcare allowance* ") Or AB(" childcare allowance* ") or TI(" child care allowance* ") or AB(" child care allowance* ") Or AB(" National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work strategyies ") or AB(" National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work strategyies ") or TI(NDLP) Or AB(NDLP) Or TI(" New Deal for Lone Parents ") or AB(" New Deal for Lone Parents ") or TI(" New Hope Project ") or AB(" New Hope Project ") or TI(" Newstart allowance ") or AB(" Newstart allowance ") or TI(NEWWS) Or AB(NEWWS) Or TI(" Ontario Works ") or AB(" Ontario Works ") or TI(Poverty) Or AB(Poverty) Or TI(PRWORA) Or AB(PRWORA) Or TI(" public welfare reform* ") or AB(" public welfare reform* ") or TI(Retrain*) or TI(Re‐train*) Or AB(Retrain*) or AB(Re‐train*) Or TI(RMI) Or AB(RMI) Or TI(sanctions) Or AB(sanctions) Or TI(" Self‐Sufficiency Project ") or AB(" Self‐Sufficiency Project ") or TI(" revenue Minimum d'Insertion ") or AB(" revenue Minimum d'Insertion ") or TI(" Social assistance ") or AB(" Social assistance ") or TI(SSP) Or AB(SSP) Or TI(TANF) Or AB(TANF) Or TI(" Temporary Assistance for Needy Families ") or AB(" Temporary Assistance for Needy Families ") or TI(" time limit* ") or AB(" time limit* ") or TI(Training) Or AB(Training) Or TI(Unemployment) Or AB(Unemployment) Or TI(Vocation*) Or AB(Vocation*) Or TI(Welfare) Or AB(Welfare) Or TI(" work first strategy* ") or AB(" work first strategy* ") or TI(" Work for your dole ") or AB(" Work for your dole ") or TI(work*) Or AB(work*) Or TI(" Working For Families ") or AB(" Working For Families ") or TI(" tax credit* ") or AB(" tax credit* ") AND (SU("unmarried mothers") OR TI("single parent*") OR AB("single parent*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("never married father*") OR AB("never married father*") OR TI("never married mother*") OR AB("never married mother*") OR TI("never married parent*") OR AB("never married parent*") OR TI("separated mother*") OR AB("separated mother*") OR TI("separated father*") OR AB("separated father*") OR TI("Single‐parent‐familyy") OR AB("Single‐parent‐familyy") OR TI("fatherless family*") OR AB("fatherless family*") OR TI("fragile family*") OR AB("fragile family*") OR TI("lone father*") OR AB("lone father*") OR TI("Lone mother*") OR AB("Lone mother*") OR TI("motherless family*") OR AB("motherless family*") OR TI("One parent*") OR AB("One parent*") OR TI("single father*") OR AB("single father*") OR TI("Single mother*") OR AB("Single mother*") OR TI("Single‐parent*") OR AB("Single‐parent*") OR TI("sole father*") OR AB("sole father*") OR TI("sole mother*") OR AB("sole mother*") OR TI("Sole parent*") OR AB("Sole parent*") OR TI("sole registrant*") OR AB("sole registrant*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("unmarried mother*") OR AB("unmarried mother*") OR TI("unwed father*") OR AB("unwed father*") OR TI(Unwed Mother* ") or AB(" Unwed Mother* ") AND (TI("quasi‐random*") OR TI("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR TI("controlled clinical trial") OR AB("quasi‐random*") OR AB("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR AB("controlled clinical trial") OR TI("clinical trial") OR TI(trial) OR TI(random*) OR AB("clinical trial") OR AB(trial) OR AB(random*)

Limits: Peer reviewed

12. Social Services Abstracts (Proquest) 16.4.16

(SU("single fathers") OR SU("single mothers") OR TI("single parent*") OR AB("single parent*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("never married father*") OR AB("never married father*") OR TI("never married mother*") OR AB("never married mother*") OR TI("never married parent*") OR AB("never married parent*") OR TI("separated mother*") OR AB("separated mother*") OR TI("separated father*") OR AB("separated father*") OR TI("Single‐parent‐family") OR AB("Single‐parent‐family") OR TI("fatherless family*") OR AB("fatherless family*") OR TI("fragile family*") OR AB("fragile family*") OR TI("lone father*") OR AB("lone father*") OR TI("Lone mother*") OR AB("Lone mother*") OR TI("motherless family*") OR AB("motherless family*") OR TI("One parent*") OR AB("One parent*") OR TI("single father*") OR AB("single father*") OR TI("Single mother*") OR AB("Single mother*") OR TI("Single‐parent*") OR AB("Single‐parent*") OR TI("sole father*") OR AB("sole father*") OR TI("sole mother*") OR AB("sole mother*") OR TI("Sole parent*") OR AB("Sole parent*") OR TI("sole registrant*") OR AB("sole registrant*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("unmarried mother*") OR AB("unmarried mother*") OR TI("unwed father*") OR AB("unwed father*") OR TI("Unwed Mother*") OR AB("Unwed Mother*")) AND (SU(income) OR SU(profits) OR SU("social security") OR SU("social welfare) or TI(" Public assistance ") or AB(" Public assistance ") OR TI(" Canada Health AND Social Transfer ") OR AB(" Canada Health AND Social Transfer ") OR TI(" Personal Responsibility AND Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act ") OR AB(" Personal Responsibility AND Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act ") OR TI(" Active labo?r market police* ") OR AB(" Active labo?r market police* ") OR TI(" Active labo?r market program* ") OR AB(" Active labo?r market program* ") OR TI(ADFC) OR AB(ADFC) OR TI(" Agenda 2010 ") OR AB(" Agenda 2010 ") OR TI(" Aid to families with Dependent Children ") OR AB(" Aid to families with Dependent Children ") OR TI(" Allocation Parent sole) OR AB(" Allocation Parent sole ") OR TI(ALMP) OR AB(ALMP) OR TI(" America Works ") OR AB(" America Works ") OR TI(API) OR AB(API) OR TI(" Back‐to‐work ") OR AB(" Back‐to‐work ") OR TI(" cash benefit* ") OR AB(" cash benefit* ") OR TI(" cash incentive* ") OR AB(" cash incentive* ") OR TI(" child care assistance ") OR AB(" child care assistance ") OR TI(" child care provision* ") OR AB(" child care provision* ") OR TI(" child care subsidy* ") OR AB(" child care subsidy* ") OR TI(" child care support ") OR AB(" child care support ") OR TI(chest) OR AB(chest) OR TI(" Community Wage ") OR AB(" Community Wage ") OR TI(" Domestic Purposes Benefit ") OR AB(" Domestic Purposes Benefit ") OR TI(" Employment Tax Deduction ") OR AB(" Employment Tax Deduction ") OR TI(" earning disregard* ") OR AB(" earning disregard* ") OR TI(employability) OR AB(employability) OR TI(Employment) OR AB(Employment) OR TI(" Employment Program* ") OR AB(" Employment Program* ") OR TI(ETD) OR AB(ETD) OR TI(income) OR AB(income) OR TI(" Public assistance ") OR AB(" Public assistance ") OR TI(" Social security ") OR AB(" Social security ") OR TI(" Social welfare ") OR AB(" Social welfare ") OR TI(" family Program* ") OR AB(" family Program* ") OR TI(" family Transition Program* ") OR AB(" family Transition Program* ") OR TI(" financial benefit* ") OR AB(" financial benefit* ") OR TI(" financial incentive* ") OR AB(" financial incentive* ") OR TI(" financial sanction* ") OR AB(" financial sanction* ") OR TI(" Financial support ") OR AB(" Financial support ") OR TI(" Financial support ") OR AB(" Financial support ") OR TI(" Financing, Government ") OR AB(" Financing, Government ") OR TI(FTP) OR AB(FTP) OR TI(" government intervention* ") OR AB(" government intervention* ") OR TI(" Government program* ") OR AB(" Government program* ") OR TI(" Government Programs ") OR AB(" Government Programs ") OR TI(" health care provision* ") OR AB(" health care provision* ") OR TI(" health care subsidy* ") OR AB(" health care subsidy* ") OR TI(" health insurance provision* ") OR AB(" health insurance provision* ") OR TI(" health insurance subsidy* ") OR AB(" health insurance subsidy* ") OR TI(" Hilfe zum Arbeit ") OR AB(" Hilfe zum Arbeit ") OR TI(" Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt ") OR AB(" Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt ") OR TI(" human capital development ") OR AB(" human capital development ") OR TI(" income benefit* ") OR AB(" income benefit* ") OR TI(" income incentive* ") OR AB(" income incentive* ") OR TI(" income supplement* ") OR AB(" income supplement* ") OR TI(" Income support ") OR AB(" Income support ") OR TI(" Individual Re‐integration Agreement ") OR AB(" Individual Re‐integration Agreement ") OR TI(IRO) OR AB(IRO) OR TI(Job) OR AB(Job) OR TI(Jobbskatteavdraget) OR AB(Jobbskatteavdraget) OR TI(Jobless*) OR AB(Jobless*) OR TI(" labo?r force attachment* ") OR AB(" labo?r force attachment* ") OR TI(" labo?r force participation ") OR AB(" labo?r force participation ") OR TI(" Labo?r market activation ") OR AB(" Labo?r market activation ") OR TI(" mandatory employment ") OR AB(" mandatory employment ") OR TI(MFIP) OR AB(MFIP) OR TI(" Minnesota family Investment Program ") OR AB(" Minnesota family Investment Program ") OR TI(" monetary benefit* ") OR AB(" monetary benefit* ") OR TI(" monetary incentive* ") OR AB(" monetary incentive* ") OR TI(" monetary support ") OR AB(" monetary support ") OR TI(" childcare allowance* ") OR AB(" childcare allowance* ") OR TI(" child care allowance* ") OR AB(" child care allowance* ") OR AB(" National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work strategyies ") OR AB(" National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work strategyies ") OR TI(NDLP) OR AB(NDLP) OR TI(" New Deal for Lone Parents ") OR AB(" New Deal for Lone Parents ") OR TI(" New Hope Project ") OR AB(" New Hope Project ") OR TI(" Newstart allowance ") OR AB(" Newstart allowance ") OR TI(news) OR AB(news) OR TI(" Ontario Works ") OR AB(" Ontario Works ") OR TI(Poverty) OR AB(Poverty) OR TI(PRWORA) OR AB(PRWORA) OR TI(" public welfare reform* ") OR AB(" public welfare reform* ") OR TI(Retrain*) OR TI(" restrain* ") OR AB(Retrain*) OR AB(" restrain* ") OR TI(RMI) OR AB(RMI) OR TI(sanctions) OR AB(sanctions) OR TI(" Self‐Sufficiency Project ") OR AB(" Self‐Sufficiency Project ") OR TI(" Revenu Minimum d'Insertion ") OR AB(" Revenu Minimum d'Insertion ") OR TI(" Social assistance ") OR AB(" Social assistance ") OR TI(SSP) OR AB(SSP) OR TI(TANF) OR AB(TANF) OR TI(" Temporary Assistance for Needy families ") OR AB(" Temporary Assistance for Needy families ") OR TI(" time limit* ") OR AB(" time limit* ") OR TI(Training) OR AB(Training) OR TI(Unemployment) OR AB(Unemployment) OR TI(Vocation*) OR AB(Vocation*) OR TI(Welfare) OR AB(Welfare) OR TI(" work first strategy* ") OR AB(" work first strategy* ") OR TI(" Work for your dole ") OR AB(" Work for your dole ") OR TI(work*) OR AB(work*) OR TI(" Working For families ") OR AB(" Working For families ") OR TI(" tax credit* ") OR AB(" tax credit* ")) AND (TI("quasi‐random*") OR TI("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR TI("controlled clinical trial") OR AB("quasi‐random*") OR AB("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR AB("controlled clinical trial") OR TI("clinical trial") OR TI(trial) OR TI(random*) OR AB("clinical trial") OR AB(trial) OR AB(random*))

Limits Peer reviewed

13. Sociological Abstracts (Proquest) 16.4.16

(SU("single fathers") OR SU("single mothers") OR SU("single parent family") OR TI("single parent*") OR ("single parent*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("never married father*") OR AB("never married father*") OR TI("never married mother*") OR AB("never married mother*") OR TI("never married parent*") OR AB("never married parent*") OR TI("separated mother*") OR AB("separated mother*") OR TI("separated father*") OR AB("separated father*") OR TI("Single‐parent‐family") OR AB("Single‐parent‐family") OR TI("fatherless family*") OR AB("fatherless family*") OR TI("fragile family*") OR AB("fragile family*") OR TI("lone father*") OR AB("lone father*") OR TI("Lone mother*") OR AB("Lone mother*") OR TI("motherless family*") OR AB("motherless family*") OR TI("One parent*") OR AB("One parent*") OR TI("single father*") OR AB("single father*") OR TI("Single mother*") OR AB("Single mother*") OR TI("Single‐parent*") OR AB("Single‐parent*") OR TI("sole father*") OR AB("sole father*") OR TI("sole mother*") OR AB("sole mother*") OR TI("Sole parent*") OR AB("Sole parent*") OR TI("sole registrant*") OR AB("sole registrant*") OR TI("unmarried father*") OR AB("unmarried father*") OR TI("unmarried mother*") OR AB("unmarried mother*") OR TI("unwed father*") OR AB("unwed father*") OR TI("Unwed Mother*") OR AB("Unwed Mother*")) AND (SU("income") OR SU("profits") OR SU("social security ") OR SU("social welfare") OR TI("Public assistance") OR AB("Public assistance") OR TI("Canada Health and Social Transfer") OR AB("Canada Health and Social Transfer") OR TI("Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act") OR AB("Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act") OR TI("Active labo?r market polic*") OR AB("Active labo?r market polic*") OR TI("Active labo?r market program*") OR AB("Active labo?r market program*") OR TI(ADFC) OR AB(ADFC) OR TI("Agenda 2010") OR AB("Agenda 2010") OR TI("Aid to Families with Dependent Children") OR AB("Aid to Families with Dependent Children") OR TI("Allocation Parent Isole") OR AB("Allocation Parent Isole") OR TI(ALMP) OR AB(ALMP) OR TI("America Works") OR AB("America Works") OR TI(API) OR AB(API) OR TI("Back‐to‐work") OR AB("Back‐to‐work") OR TI("cash benefit*") OR AB("cash benefit*") OR TI("cash incentive*") OR AB("cash incentive*") OR TI("child care assistance") OR AB("child care assistance") OR TI("child care provision*") OR AB("child care provision*") OR TI("child care subsidy*") OR AB("child care subsidy*") OR TI("child care support") OR AB("child care support") OR TI(chest) OR AB(chest) OR TI("Community Wage") OR AB("Community Wage") OR TI("Domestic Purposes Benefit") OR AB("Domestic Purposes Benefit") OR TI("Employment Tax Deduction") OR AB("Employment Tax Deduction") OR TI("earning disregard*") OR AB("earning disregard*") OR TI(employability) OR AB(employability) OR TI(Employment) OR AB(Employment) OR TI("Employment Program*") OR AB("Employment Program*") OR TI(ETD) OR AB(ETD) OR TI(income) OR AB(income) OR TI("Public assistance") OR AB("Public assistance") OR TI("Social security") OR AB("Social security") OR TI("Social welfare") OR AB("Social welfare") OR TI("family Program*") OR AB("family Program*") OR TI("family Transition Program*") OR AB("family Transition Program*") OR TI("financial benefit*") OR AB("financial benefit*") OR TI("financial incentive*") OR AB("financial incentive*") OR TI("financial sanction*") OR AB("financial sanction*") OR TI("Financial support") OR AB("Financial support") OR TI("Financial support") OR AB("Financial support") OR TI("Financing, Government") OR AB("Financing, Government") OR TI(FTP) OR AB(FTP) OR TI("government intervention*") OR AB("government intervention*") OR TI("Government program*") OR AB("Government program*") OR TI("Government Programs") OR AB("Government Programs") OR TI("health care provision*") OR AB("health care provision*") OR TI("health care subsidy*") OR AB("health care subsidy*") OR TI("health insurance provision*") OR AB("health insurance provision*") OR TI("health insurance subsidy*") OR AB("health insurance subsidy*") OR TI("Hilfe zum Arbeit") OR AB("Hilfe zum Arbeit") OR TI("Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt") OR AB("Hilfe zum Lebensunterhalt") OR TI("human capital development") OR AB("human capital development") OR TI("income benefit*") OR AB("income benefit*") OR TI("income incentive*") OR AB("income incentive*") OR TI("income supplement*") OR AB("income supplement*") OR TI("Income support") OR AB("Income support") OR TI("Individual Re‐integration Agreement") OR AB("Individual Re‐integration Agreement") OR TI(IRO) OR AB(IRO) OR TI(Job) OR AB(Job) OR TI(Jobbskatteavdraget) OR AB(Jobbskatteavdraget) OR TI(Jobless*) OR AB(Jobless*) OR TI("labo?r force attachment*") OR AB("labo?r force attachment*") OR TI("labo?r force participation") OR AB("labo?r force participation") OR TI("Labo?r market activation") OR AB("Labo?r market activation") OR TI("mandatory employment") OR AB("mandatory employment") OR TI(MFIP) OR AB(MFIP) OR TI("Minnesota family Investment Program") OR AB("Minnesota family Investment Program") OR TI("monetary benefit*") OR AB("monetary benefit*") OR TI("monetary incentive*") OR AB("monetary incentive*") OR TI("monetary support") OR AB("monetary support") OR TI("childcare allowance*") OR AB("childcare allowance*") OR TI("child care allowance*") OR AB("child care allowance*") OR AB("National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work strategyies") OR AB("National Evaluation of Welfare‐to work strategyies") OR TI(NDLP) OR AB(NDLP) OR TI("New Deal for Lone Parents") OR AB("New Deal for Lone Parents") OR TI("New Hope Project") OR AB("New Hope Project") OR TI("Newstart allowance") OR AB("Newstart allowance") OR TI(news) OR AB(news) OR TI("Ontario Works") OR AB("Ontario Works") OR TI(Poverty) OR AB(Poverty) OR TI(PRWORA) OR AB(PRWORA) OR TI("public welfare reform*") OR AB("public welfare reform*") OR TI(Retrain*) OR TI(restrain*) OR AB(Retrain*) OR AB(restrain*) OR TI(RMI) OR AB(RMI) OR TI(sanctions) OR AB(sanctions) OR TI("Self‐Sufficiency Project") OR AB("Self‐Sufficiency Project") OR TI("Revenu Minimum d'Insertion") OR AB("Revenu Minimum d'Insertion") OR TI("Social assistance") OR AB("Social assistance") OR TI(SSP) OR AB(SSP) OR TI(TANF) OR AB(TANF) OR TI("Temporary Assistance for Needy Families ") OR AB("Temporary Assistance for Needy Families ") OR TI("time limit*") OR AB("time limit*") OR TI(Training) OR AB(Training) OR TI(Unemployment) OR AB(Unemployment) OR TI(Vocation*) OR AB(Vocation*) OR TI(Welfare) OR AB(Welfare) OR TI("work first strategy*") OR AB("work first strategy*") OR TI("Work for your dole") OR AB("Work for your dole") OR TI(work*) OR AB(work*) OR TI("Working For Families ") OR AB("Working For Families ") OR TI("tax credit*") OR AB("tax credit*")) AND (TI("quasi‐random*") OR TI("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR TI("controlled clinical trial") OR AB("quasi‐random*") OR AB("randomi?ed controlled trial") OR AB("controlled clinical trial") OR TI("clinical trial") OR TI("trial") OR TI("random*") OR AB("clinical trial") OR AB(trial) OR AB(random*))

Limits Peer reviewed

14. Campbell Library

Parent* OR welfare*

15. NHS Economic Evaluation Database (NHS EED)

(parent*) OR (welfare*)

16. Turning Research Into Practice (TRIP);

"one parent* or "lone Parent*" or "single parent*" or "single mother*") and welfare

17. Open Grey

"one parent" and work*

18. Planex

("one parent families" or "lone parent" or "single parent*" or "single mother*") and (employment or welfare*)

Appendix 3. Websites searched

Institution/Project

References found

Studies identified for detailed screening

Abt Associates Inc.

245

1

Administration for Children and Families Office of Planning, Research & Evaluation

226

13

Australian Government Employment and Workplace Relations

NA

0

Australian Institute of Family Studies

NA

0

British Library‐ welfare reform on the web

118

3

Brookings Institution

50

0

Canadian Social Research Links

152

0

Cato Institute

NA

0

Center for Quality Assurance and Policy Studies

NA

0

Center for Social Services Research

2

0

Center on Budget and Policy Priorities

2432

0

Centre for Economic and Social Inclusion

NA

0

Centre for Market and Public Organisation (Bristol)

NA

0

Chapin Hall (Chicago)

40

0

Department for Work and Pensions

223

7

Department of Social and Family Affairs, Ireland

NA

0

Department of Social and Policy Sciences, Bath

NA

0

Does 'Work for the dole' work?

NA

0

Employment Research Institute

NA

0

Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy

90

5

Government of Western Australia, Department of Health

NA

0

Heritage Foundation

NA

0

Human Capability and Resilience research project

NA

0

Human Resources and Skills Development Canada

NA

0

Institute for Fiscal Studies

NA

0

Institute for Policy Research

215

7

Institute for Public Policy Research

96

0

Institute for Research on Poverty

732

55

Institute of Economic Affairs

26

0

Joseph Rowntree Foundation

NA

0

Manhattan Institute

NA

0

Manpower Demonstration Research Corporation/MDRC

174

56

Maryland Institute for Policy Analysis and Research

NA

0

Mathemetica Policy Research Inc.

103

1

Ministry of Social Development, New Zealand

NA

0

National Bureau of Economic Research

31

12

National Centre for Social Research

NA

0

National Evaluation of Welfare to Work strategies

27

22

National Poverty Center (Michigan)

73

15

New South Wales Office for Women

NA

1

Norwegian Government

NA

0

One Family

NA

0

Pioneer Institute

NA

0

Policy Library

NA

0

Policy Studies Institute

NA

0

RAND Corporation

523

8

Ray Marshall Centre

104

2

Research Connections

823

19

Robert Wood Johnson Foundation

29

0

Social Policy Digest

NA

0

Social Research and Demonstration Corporation, Canada

90

8

Statistics Norway

47

0

The Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion

NA

0

The Institute for Employment Studies

56

0

The Institute for Labour Market Policy Evaluation, Sweden

102

0

The Research Forum

54

51

The Urban Institute

1219

6

US Government Accountability Office

580

3

WE Upjohn Institute

35

0

Total

8717 E

275

Websites with search interfaces or searchable database were searched using terms such as 'lone parent' 'lone parent welfare' 'welfare reform' or 'welfare health'. Otherwise the relevant publications topic in a website was screened. Where this was possible, the number of initial 'hits' is listed. NA = no searchable interface. Total is an estimate due to websites without searchable interfaces.

Appendix 4. Risk of bias for studies with a separate control group

Was the allocation sequence adequately generated?

Score "Yes" if a random component in the sequence generation process is described (e.g. referring to a random number table). Score "No" when a nonrandom method is used (e.g. performed by date of admission). Controlled clinical trials (CCTs) and controlled before‐and‐after studies (CBAs) should be scored "No". Score "Unclear" if not specified in the paper.

Was the allocation adequately concealed?

Score "Yes" if the unit of allocation was by institution, team or professional and allocation was performed on all units at the start of the study; or if the unit of allocation was by patient or episode of care and there was some form of centralised randomisation scheme, an on‐site computer system or sealed opaque envelopes were used. CBAs should be scored "No". Score "unclear" if not specified in the paper. 

Were baseline outcome measurements similar?

Score "Yes" if performance or patient outcomes were measured prior to the intervention, and no important differences were present across study groups. In RCTs, score "Yes" if imbalanced but appropriate adjusted analysis was performed (e.g. analysis of covariance). Score "No" if important differences were present and not adjusted for in analysis. If RCTs have no baseline measure of outcome, score "Unclear". 

Were baseline characteristics similar?

Score "Yes" if baseline characteristics of the study and control providers are reported and similar. Score "Unclear" if it is not clear in the paper (e.g. characteristics are mentioned in text but no data were presented). Score "No" if there is no report of characteristics in text or tables or if there are differences between control and intervention providers. Note that in some cases imbalance in patient characteristics may be due to recruitment bias whereby the provider was responsible for recruiting patients into the trial. 

Were incomplete outcome data adequately addressed?

Score "Yes" if missing outcome measures were unlikely to bias the results (e.g. the proportion of missing data was similar in the intervention and control groups or the proportion of missing data was less than the effect size i.e. unlikely to overturn the study result). Score "No" if missing outcome data was likely to bias the results. Score "Unclear" if not specified in the paper (do not assume 100% follow up unless stated explicitly). 

Was knowledge of the allocated interventions adequately prevented during the study?

Score "Yes" if the authors state explicitly that the primary outcome variables were assessed blindly, or the outcomes are objective, e.g. length of hospital stay. Primary outcomes are those variables that correspond to the primary hypothesis or question as defined by the authors. Score "No" if the outcomes were not assessed blindly. Score "unclear" if not specified in the paper. 

Was the study adequately protected against contamination?

Score "Yes" if allocation was by community, institution or practice and it is unlikely that the control group received the intervention. Score "No" if it is likely that the control group received the intervention (e.g. if patients rather than professionals were randomised). Score "unclear" if professionals were allocated within a clinic or practice and it is possible that communication between intervention and control professionals could have occurred (e.g. physicians within practices were allocated to intervention or control). 

Was the study free from selective outcome reporting?

Score "Yes" if there is no evidence that outcomes were selectively reported (e.g. all relevant outcomes in the methods section are reported in the results section). Score "No" if some important outcomes are subsequently omitted from the results. Score "unclear" if not specified in the paper. 

Was the study free from other risks of bias?

Score "Yes" if there is no evidence of other risk of biases. If some primary outcomes were imbalanced at baseline, assessed blindly or affected by missing data and others were not, each primary outcome can be scored separately. If "Unclear" or "No", but there is sufficient data in the paper to do an adjusted analysis (e.g. baseline adjustment analysis or intention to treat analysis) the criteria should be rescored to "Yes".

Appendix 5. All reported outcomes by study

1. Maternal mental health

Study

CES‐D mean

CES‐D % at risk

CIDI % at risk

Self‐report

Timepoint 1

CJF GUP 2000

threshold NR

CJF Yale 2001

≥16/60

New Hope 1999

x

NEWWS 2001

x

Ontario 2001

threshold NR

Timepoint 2

CJF 2002

x

CJF GUP 2000

x

FTP 2000

x

California GAIN 1994

x

MFIP 2000

x

≥23/60

Ontario 2001

SSP Recipients 2002

x

Timepoint 3

IFIP 2002

≥23/60

IWRE 2002

x

New Hope 1999

x

NEWWS 2001

SSP Applicants 2003

x

SSP Recipients 2002

x

UK ERA 2011

x

2. Maternal physical health

Study

In poor health (%)

In good health (%)

Physical health scale

Timepoint 1

CJF GUP 2000

CJF Yale 2001

x

New Hope 1999

NEWWS 2001

Ontario 2001

Timepoint 2

CJF 2002

CJF GUP 2000

FTP 2000

California GAIN 1994

x

MFIP 2000

Ontario 2001

x

SSP Recipients 2002

Timepoint 3

IFIP 2002

IWRE 2002

New Hope 1999

x

NEWWS 2001

SSP Applicants 2003

SSP Recipients 2002

UK ERA 2011

x

3. Child mental health

Behavior problems total score (mean)

Behavior problems (% with problems)

Number of behavior problems

% at risk for depression

Timepoint 1

CJF GUP 2000

CJF Yale 2001

x

New Hope 1999

NEWWS 2001

x

Ontario 2001

x

Timepoint 2

CJF 2002

x

CJF GUP 2000

FTP 2000

x

California GAIN 1994

MFIP 2000

x

Ontario 2001

SSP Recipients 2002

x

Timepoint 3

IFIP 2002

x

IWRE 2002

x

New Hope 1999

NEWWS 2001

x

SSP Applicants 2003

x

SSP Recipients 2002

x

UK ERA 2011

4. Child physical health

Mother reported health (mean score)

Good/excellent or fair/poor health (%)

Timepoint 1

CJF GUP 2000

CJF Yale 2001

New Hope 1999

NEWWS 2001

x

Ontario 2001

Timepoint 2

CJF 2002

x

CJF GUP 2000

FTP 2000

x

California GAIN 1994

MFIP 2000

x

Ontario 2001

SSP Recipients 2002

x

Timepoint 3

IFIP 2002

x

IWRE 2002

x

New Hope 1999

x

NEWWS 2001

x

SSP Recipients 2002

x

SSP Applicants 2003

x

UK ERA 2011

5. Employment status

Currently employed (%)

Currently employed FT (%)

Currently employed PT (%)

Ever employed since RA/in year of study (%)

Ever employed FT since RA/in year of study (%)

Ever employed PT since RA/in year of survey (%)

Timepoint 1

CJF GUP 2000

x

CJF Yale 2001

x

x

New Hope 1999

x

NEWWS 2001

x

x

Ontario 2001

Timepoint 2

CJF 2002

x

CJF GUP 2000

FTP 2000

x

California GAIN 1994

x

x

x

MFIP 2000

x

x

x

Ontario 2001

SSP Recipients 2002

x

x

x

x

Timepoint 3

IFIP 2002

x

x

x

IWRE 2002

x

New Hope 1999

x

x

NEWWS 2001

x

x

x

x

SSP Applicants 2003

x

x

x

SSP Recipients 2002

x

x

x

UK ERA 2011

x

x

x

x

6. Income

Total income (USD/CAD)

Earnings (USD/CAD/GBP)

Timepoint 1

CJF GUP 2000

CJF Yale 2001

New Hope 1999

x

x

NEWWS 2001

x

x

Ontario 2001

Timepoint 2

CJF 2002

x

x

CJF GUP 2000

FTP 2000

x

x

California GAIN 1994

x

MFIP 2000

x

x

Ontario 2001

SSP Recipients 2002

x

x

Timepoint 3

IFIP 2002

x

x

IWRE 2002

x

x

New Hope 1999

x

x

NEWWS 2001

x

x

SSP Applicants 2003

x

x

SSP Recipients 2002

x

x

UK ERA 2011

x

7. Welfare Receipt

Total benefit received (USD/CAD/GBP)

Receiving benefits currently or in year of study (%)

Timepoint 1

CJF GUP 2000

CJF Yale 2001

New Hope 1999

x

x

NEWWS 2001

x

Ontario 2001

x

Timepoint 2

CJF 2002

x

CJF GUP 2000

FTP 2000

x

California GAIN 1994

MFIP 2000

x

Ontario 2001

x

SSP Recipients 2002

x

Timepoint 3

IFIP 2002

x

x

IWRE 2002

x

x

New Hope 1999

x

x

NEWWS 2001

x

SSP Applicants 2003

x

x

SSP Recipients 2002

x

x

UK ERA 2011

x

x

8. Health insurance

Adult Health Insurance

Child Health Insurance

Family Health Insurance

Timepoint 1

CJF GUP 2000

x

CJF Yale 2001

x

New Hope 1999

x

NEWWS 2001

x

x

Ontario 2001

Timepoint 2

CJF 2002

x

CJF GUP 2000

FTP 2000

California GAIN 1994

x

MFIP 2000

x

Ontario 2001

SSP Recipients 2002

Timepoint 3

IFIP 2002

x

IWRE 2002

New Hope 1999

x

x

NEWWS 2001

x

SSP Applicants 2003

SSP Recipients 2002

UK ERA 2011

Appendix 6. MDRC sequence generation procedure

Provided by Cynthia Miller, MDRC 16/9/11

"Like comparable research organizations, MDRC’s random assignment process is regulated by a control file consisting of the sequence of assignment values. Simple random assignment is not generally used at MDRC because social programs often have quotas related to how many individuals can be served in a given site during a given time period. Therefore, MDRC goes to great lengths to make control files as unpredictable as possible while at the same time avoiding localized ‘bad draws’ that could adversely affect program operations.

MDRC’s random assignment process is regulated by a '“sequence'” file consisting of the ordering of assignment values. Each project gets its own sequence file – they are never reused. The sequence files are constructed by defining blocks of assignments, each block made up of different sizes configured to approximate the intended random assignment ratio. The size of the blocks generally average over 20 assignments; the assignments within each block are randomized using an available random number generator with a uniform distribution. We generally use 9 different block sizes, and the order of block sizes is also randomized, with each block size occurring exactly once within a ‘superblock’ of the 9 block sizes. Each superblock is calculated to generate precisely the targeted random assignment ratio. Within a superblock a given block may not necessarily exactly match the target random assignment ratio, but any deviance from the target in one block will be compensated for in another block. This is especially necessary when an odd‐sized random assignment ratio is specified (e.g., 55:45).

Each time a control file is generated, we produce many more versions than we need. For each version we calculate an entropy measure that reflects the distribution among configurations of possible subpatterns within the control file. We use this entropy measure to gauge the extent to which a given sequence file could reveal information from the pattern of past assignments to help anticipate future assignments. For the research study we will choose a sequence file from among the ones generated that contain the highest overall entropy; that is, they tend to have a more uniform distribution of distinct subpatterns. The higher the entropy the more likely it is that subpatterns are equally likely and therefore are unpredictable. For example, within the constraints of the overall average block size, maximizing the entropy of the sequence would mean that a subpatterns like “ECECEC”, “EEEEEE”, “CECCCE” and “EEECCC” would all tend to be equally likely within the overall sequence file."

Study flow diagram.*An initial stage of screening reduced records from all other sources to 1609. The remaining records were then de‐duplicated against the Endnote library containing the electronic search results. Note this figure does not include publications found on websites without searchable databases.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 1

Study flow diagram.

*An initial stage of screening reduced records from all other sources to 1609. The remaining records were then de‐duplicated against the Endnote library containing the electronic search results. Note this figure does not include publications found on websites without searchable databases.

Age of children at time of data collection by time point
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 2

Age of children at time of data collection by time point

Example of study logic model from NEWWS 2001 Copyright © 2001 MDRC: reproduced with permission.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 3

Example of study logic model from NEWWS 2001 Copyright © 2001 MDRC: reproduced with permission.

original image
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 4

Risk of bias summary: review authors' judgements about each risk of bias item for each included study.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 5

Risk of bias summary: review authors' judgements about each risk of bias item for each included study.

Risk of bias graph: review authors' judgements about each risk of bias item presented as percentages across all included studies.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 6

Risk of bias graph: review authors' judgements about each risk of bias item presented as percentages across all included studies.

Forest plot of comparison: 1 Time point 1 Maternal mental health, outcome: 1.1 Maternal mental health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 7

Forest plot of comparison: 1 Time point 1 Maternal mental health, outcome: 1.1 Maternal mental health continuous.

Forest plot of comparison: 2 Time point 2 Maternal mental health, outcome: 2.1 Maternal mental health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 8

Forest plot of comparison: 2 Time point 2 Maternal mental health, outcome: 2.1 Maternal mental health continuous.

Forest plot of comparison: 3 Time point 3 Maternal mental health, outcome: 3.1 Maternal mental health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 9

Forest plot of comparison: 3 Time point 3 Maternal mental health, outcome: 3.1 Maternal mental health continuous.

Forest plot of comparison: 4 Time point 1 Maternal physical health, outcome: 4.1 In poor health (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 10

Forest plot of comparison: 4 Time point 1 Maternal physical health, outcome: 4.1 In poor health (%).

Forest plot of comparison: 5 Time point 2 Maternal physical health, outcome: 5.1 In good or excellent health %. Event defined as In good or excellent health.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 11

Forest plot of comparison: 5 Time point 2 Maternal physical health, outcome: 5.1 In good or excellent health %. Event defined as In good or excellent health.

Forest plot of comparison: 6 Time point 3 Maternal physical health, outcome: 6.1 Self‐reported health (1‐5).
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 12

Forest plot of comparison: 6 Time point 3 Maternal physical health, outcome: 6.1 Self‐reported health (1‐5).

Forest plot of comparison: 7 Time point 1 Child mental health, outcome: 7.1 Child behaviour problems continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 13

Forest plot of comparison: 7 Time point 1 Child mental health, outcome: 7.1 Child behaviour problems continuous.

Forest plot of comparison: 8 Time point 2 Child mental health, outcome: 8.1 Child behaviour problems continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 14

Forest plot of comparison: 8 Time point 2 Child mental health, outcome: 8.1 Child behaviour problems continuous.

Forest plot of comparison: 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, outcome: 9.1 Child behaviour problems continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 15

Forest plot of comparison: 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, outcome: 9.1 Child behaviour problems continuous.

Forest plot of comparison: 10 Time point 1 Child physical health, outcome: 10.1 General health rating (1‐5).
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 16

Forest plot of comparison: 10 Time point 1 Child physical health, outcome: 10.1 General health rating (1‐5).

Forest plot of comparison: 11 Time point 2 Child physical health, outcome: 11.1 Child physical health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 17

Forest plot of comparison: 11 Time point 2 Child physical health, outcome: 11.1 Child physical health continuous.

Forest plot of comparison: 12 Time point 3 Child physical health, outcome: 12.1 Child physical health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Figure 18

Forest plot of comparison: 12 Time point 3 Child physical health, outcome: 12.1 Child physical health continuous.

Comparison 1 Time point 1 Maternal mental health, Outcome 1 Maternal mental health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 1.1

Comparison 1 Time point 1 Maternal mental health, Outcome 1 Maternal mental health continuous.

Comparison 1 Time point 1 Maternal mental health, Outcome 2 Maternal mental health dichotomous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 1.2

Comparison 1 Time point 1 Maternal mental health, Outcome 2 Maternal mental health dichotomous.

Comparison 2 Time point 2 Maternal mental health, Outcome 1 Maternal mental health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 2.1

Comparison 2 Time point 2 Maternal mental health, Outcome 1 Maternal mental health continuous.

Study

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Total n

Sig

CJF GUP 2000

15.5

Not reported

13.9

Not reported

187

< 0.10

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 2.2

Comparison 2 Time point 2 Maternal mental health, Outcome 2 CJF GUP CES‐D mean score (0‐60).

Comparison 2 Time point 2 Maternal mental health, Outcome 3 Maternal mental health dichotomous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 2.3

Comparison 2 Time point 2 Maternal mental health, Outcome 3 Maternal mental health dichotomous.

Comparison 3 Time point 3 Maternal mental health, Outcome 1 Maternal mental health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 3.1

Comparison 3 Time point 3 Maternal mental health, Outcome 1 Maternal mental health continuous.

Comparison 3 Time point 3 Maternal mental health, Outcome 2 Maternal mental health dichotomous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 3.2

Comparison 3 Time point 3 Maternal mental health, Outcome 2 Maternal mental health dichotomous.

Comparison 4 Time point 1 Maternal physical health, Outcome 1 In poor health (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 4.1

Comparison 4 Time point 1 Maternal physical health, Outcome 1 In poor health (%).

Comparison 5 Time point 2 Maternal physical health, Outcome 1 In good or excellent health (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 5.1

Comparison 5 Time point 2 Maternal physical health, Outcome 1 In good or excellent health (%).

Comparison 6 Time point 3 Maternal physical health, Outcome 1 Self‐reported health (1‐5).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 6.1

Comparison 6 Time point 3 Maternal physical health, Outcome 1 Self‐reported health (1‐5).

Comparison 6 Time point 3 Maternal physical health, Outcome 2 In good or very good health (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 6.2

Comparison 6 Time point 3 Maternal physical health, Outcome 2 In good or very good health (%).

Comparison 7 Time point 1 Child mental health, Outcome 1 Child behaviour problems continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 7.1

Comparison 7 Time point 1 Child mental health, Outcome 1 Child behaviour problems continuous.

Comparison 7 Time point 1 Child mental health, Outcome 2 Child behaviour problems dichotomous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 7.2

Comparison 7 Time point 1 Child mental health, Outcome 2 Child behaviour problems dichotomous.

Comparison 8 Time point 2 Child mental health, Outcome 1 Child behaviour problems continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 8.1

Comparison 8 Time point 2 Child mental health, Outcome 1 Child behaviour problems continuous.

Comparison 8 Time point 2 Child mental health, Outcome 2 Adolescent mental health dichotomous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 8.2

Comparison 8 Time point 2 Child mental health, Outcome 2 Adolescent mental health dichotomous.

Study

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Total N

CJF GUP 2000

1.7

Not reported

1.6

Not reported

182

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 8.3

Comparison 8 Time point 2 Child mental health, Outcome 3 Child Behavior Checklist (1‐3).

Comparison 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, Outcome 1 Child behaviour problems continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 9.1

Comparison 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, Outcome 1 Child behaviour problems continuous.

Comparison 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, Outcome 2 Child behaviour problem continuous excluding SSP Applicants.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 9.2

Comparison 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, Outcome 2 Child behaviour problem continuous excluding SSP Applicants.

Comparison 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, Outcome 3 NEWWS 2001 Child mental health.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 9.3

Comparison 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, Outcome 3 NEWWS 2001 Child mental health.

Study

Group

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Sig

IFIP 2002

Ongoing recipients

11.8

540

12.0

273

NS

IFIP 2002

Applicants

11.3

442

10.9

220

NS

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 9.4

Comparison 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, Outcome 4 IFIP Behavioral Problems Index (0‐56).

Study

Child age

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Sig.

SSP Recipients 2002

5.5‐7.5 years at follow up

1.3

554

1.3

605

NS

SSP Recipients 2002

7.5‐9.5 years at follow up

1.3

577

1.3

560

NS

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 9.5

Comparison 9 Time point 3 Child mental health, Outcome 5 SSP‐R T3 Behavior Problems Scale (1‐3).

Comparison 10 Time point 1 Child physical health, Outcome 1 General health rating (1‐5).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 10.1

Comparison 10 Time point 1 Child physical health, Outcome 1 General health rating (1‐5).

Comparison 11 Time point 2 Child physical health, Outcome 1 Child physical health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 11.1

Comparison 11 Time point 2 Child physical health, Outcome 1 Child physical health continuous.

Comparison 11 Time point 2 Child physical health, Outcome 2 Child physical health dichotomous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 11.2

Comparison 11 Time point 2 Child physical health, Outcome 2 Child physical health dichotomous.

Comparison 12 Time point 3 Child physical health, Outcome 1 Child physical health continuous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 12.1

Comparison 12 Time point 3 Child physical health, Outcome 1 Child physical health continuous.

Comparison 12 Time point 3 Child physical health, Outcome 2 Child physical health dichotomous.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 12.2

Comparison 12 Time point 3 Child physical health, Outcome 2 Child physical health dichotomous.

Comparison 13 Time point 1 Employment status, Outcome 1 Currently employed (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 13.1

Comparison 13 Time point 1 Employment status, Outcome 1 Currently employed (%).

Comparison 13 Time point 1 Employment status, Outcome 2 Ever employed (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 13.2

Comparison 13 Time point 1 Employment status, Outcome 2 Ever employed (%).

Comparison 14 Time point 2 Employment status, Outcome 1 Ever employed (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 14.1

Comparison 14 Time point 2 Employment status, Outcome 1 Ever employed (%).

Comparison 14 Time point 2 Employment status, Outcome 2 Ever employed full‐time since randomisation (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 14.2

Comparison 14 Time point 2 Employment status, Outcome 2 Ever employed full‐time since randomisation (%).

Comparison 14 Time point 2 Employment status, Outcome 3 Ever employed full‐time excluding MFIP (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 14.3

Comparison 14 Time point 2 Employment status, Outcome 3 Ever employed full‐time excluding MFIP (%).

Comparison 14 Time point 2 Employment status, Outcome 4 Employed part‐time (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 14.4

Comparison 14 Time point 2 Employment status, Outcome 4 Employed part‐time (%).

Comparison 15 Time point 3 Employment status, Outcome 1 Currently employed (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 15.1

Comparison 15 Time point 3 Employment status, Outcome 1 Currently employed (%).

Comparison 15 Time point 3 Employment status, Outcome 2 Ever employed (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 15.2

Comparison 15 Time point 3 Employment status, Outcome 2 Ever employed (%).

Comparison 15 Time point 3 Employment status, Outcome 3 Currently employed full‐time (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 15.3

Comparison 15 Time point 3 Employment status, Outcome 3 Currently employed full‐time (%).

Comparison 15 Time point 3 Employment status, Outcome 4 Currently employed part‐time (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 15.4

Comparison 15 Time point 3 Employment status, Outcome 4 Currently employed part‐time (%).

Comparison 16 Time point 1 Income, Outcome 1 Total income.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 16.1

Comparison 16 Time point 1 Income, Outcome 1 Total income.

Comparison 16 Time point 1 Income, Outcome 2 Earnings.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 16.2

Comparison 16 Time point 1 Income, Outcome 2 Earnings.

Study

Intervention group

I nt

n

C ont

n

Sig

NEWWS 2001

Atlanta Human Capital Development

343

520

289

506

.0.1

NEWWS 2001

Atlanta Labour Force Attachment

326

396

293

506

NS

NEWWS 2001

Grand Rapids Human Capital Development

336

205

341

216

NS

NEWWS 2001

Grand Rapids Labour Force Attachment

392

225

345

216

NS

NEWWS 2001

Riverside Labour Force Attachment

337

208

197

486

0.001

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 16.3

Comparison 16 Time point 1 Income, Outcome 3 NEWWS T1 Average earnings previous month (USD).

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 1 Total income.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 17.1

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 1 Total income.

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 2 Total income excluding CJF.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 17.2

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 2 Total income excluding CJF.

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 3 Average earnings in year of survey (USD).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 17.3

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 3 Average earnings in year of survey (USD).

Study

Group

MFIP

MFIP‐IO

Control

MFIP n

MFIP‐IO n

Cont n

Sig

MFIP 2000

Long‐term urban recipients

4657

3,967

3906

306

292

281

NS

MFIP 2000

Recent urban recipients

6817

6,270

7438

258

135

259

NS

MFIP 2000

Long‐term rural recipients

4061

NA

4139

92

NA

105

NS

MFIP 2000

Recent rural recipients

6530

NA

5854

97

NA

75

NS

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 17.4

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 4 MFIP Average annual earnings years 1‐3 (USD).

Study

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Sample

Sig

California GAIN 1994

204

1076

190

648

Employed respondents only

No test conducted

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 17.5

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 5 GAIN Average weekly earnings since randomisation (USD).

Study

Intervention mean

Intervention n

Control mean

Control n

FTP 2000

6177

543

5208

565

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 17.6

Comparison 17 Time point 2 Income, Outcome 6 FTP Average earnings in year of study (USD).

Comparison 18 Time point 3 Income, Outcome 1 Total income.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 18.1

Comparison 18 Time point 3 Income, Outcome 1 Total income.

Study

Group

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Sig

IFIP 2002

Ongoing

1533

540

1451

273

NS

IFIP 2002

Applicant

1857

442

2110

220

0.05

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 18.2

Comparison 18 Time point 3 Income, Outcome 2 IFIP household income month prior to survey (USD).

Comparison 18 Time point 3 Income, Outcome 3 Total earnings.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 18.3

Comparison 18 Time point 3 Income, Outcome 3 Total earnings.

Study

Group

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Sig

IFIP 2002

Ongoing

816

540

808

273

NS

IFIP 2002

Applicant

1053

442

1117

220

NS

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 18.4

Comparison 18 Time point 3 Income, Outcome 4 IFIP Average earnings month prior to survey (USD).

Study

Group

int

N

cont

N

Sig

NEWWS 2001

Atlanta Human Capital Development

22,961

367

20,516

311

NS

NEWWS 2001

Atlanta Labour Force Attachment

23,063

289

20,516

311

NS

NEWWS 2001

Grand Rapids Human Capital Development

23,975

196

23,340

214

NS

NEWWS 2001

Grand Rapids Labour Force Attachment

26,625

214

23,340

214

NS

NEWWS 2001

Riverside Labour Force Attachment

17,342

185

10,805

348

0.01

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 18.5

Comparison 18 Time point 3 Income, Outcome 5 NEWWS T3 Average earnings years 1‐5 (USD).

Comparison 19 Time point 1 Welfare receipt, Outcome 1 Total AFDC received year 2 (USD).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 19.1

Comparison 19 Time point 1 Welfare receipt, Outcome 1 Total AFDC received year 2 (USD).

Comparison 19 Time point 1 Welfare receipt, Outcome 2 Proportion of sample receiving welfare (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 19.2

Comparison 19 Time point 1 Welfare receipt, Outcome 2 Proportion of sample receiving welfare (%).

Comparison 20 Time point 2 Welfare receipt, Outcome 1 Average annual welfare benefit.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 20.1

Comparison 20 Time point 2 Welfare receipt, Outcome 1 Average annual welfare benefit.

Comparison 20 Time point 2 Welfare receipt, Outcome 2 Average annual welfare benefit excluding MFIP.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 20.2

Comparison 20 Time point 2 Welfare receipt, Outcome 2 Average annual welfare benefit excluding MFIP.

Comparison 20 Time point 2 Welfare receipt, Outcome 3 Proportion of sample receiving welfare.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 20.3

Comparison 20 Time point 2 Welfare receipt, Outcome 3 Proportion of sample receiving welfare.

Comparison 21 Time point 3 Welfare receipt, Outcome 1 Total welfare benefit received.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 21.1

Comparison 21 Time point 3 Welfare receipt, Outcome 1 Total welfare benefit received.

Comparison 21 Time point 3 Welfare receipt, Outcome 2 Total welfare payments years 1‐5 (USD).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 21.2

Comparison 21 Time point 3 Welfare receipt, Outcome 2 Total welfare payments years 1‐5 (USD).

Study

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Total n

Sig.

IWRE 2002

685

819

1082

860

1679

< 0.01

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 21.3

Comparison 21 Time point 3 Welfare receipt, Outcome 3 IWRE TANF receipt month before survey, annualised year 5 (USD).

Study

Group

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Sig.

IFIP 2002

Ongoing

111

540

103

273

NS

IFIP 2002

Applicant

56

442

34

220

< 0.05

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 21.4

Comparison 21 Time point 3 Welfare receipt, Outcome 4 IFIP Average welfare received month prior to survey (USD).

Comparison 21 Time point 3 Welfare receipt, Outcome 5 Proportion of sample receiving welfare.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 21.5

Comparison 21 Time point 3 Welfare receipt, Outcome 5 Proportion of sample receiving welfare.

Comparison 22 Time point 1 Health insurance, Outcome 1 Respondent has health insurance (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 22.1

Comparison 22 Time point 1 Health insurance, Outcome 1 Respondent has health insurance (%).

Comparison 22 Time point 1 Health insurance, Outcome 2 Child health insurance (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 22.2

Comparison 22 Time point 1 Health insurance, Outcome 2 Child health insurance (%).

Comparison 23 Time point 2 Health insurance, Outcome 1 Health insurance (%).
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 23.1

Comparison 23 Time point 2 Health insurance, Outcome 1 Health insurance (%).

Comparison 24 Time point 3 Health insurance, Outcome 1 Health insurance.
Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 24.1

Comparison 24 Time point 3 Health insurance, Outcome 1 Health insurance.

Study

Outcome

Group

Intervention

Int n

Control

Cont n

Total n

P value

Effect size

New Hope 1999

Physical health (mean score) (1‐5)

Parents

3.2

NR

3.22

NR

595

0.82

0.02

New Hope 1999

CES‐D mean score (0‐60)

Parents

17.36

NR

17.33

NR

595

0.98

0.00

New Hope 1999

Problem Behavior Scale Externalising subscore

Boys

2.34

NR

2.45

NR

570

0.107

0.15

New Hope 1999

Problem Behavior Scale Externalising subscore

Girls

2.34

NR

2.3

NR

531

0.615

0.05

New Hope 1999

Problem Behavior Scale Internalising subscore

Boys

2.29

NR

2.39

NR

570

0.148

0.15

New Hope 1999

Problem Behavior Scale Internalising subscore

Girls

2.32

NR

2.35

NR

531

0.664

0.04

Figuras y tablas -
Analysis 25.1

Comparison 25 New Hope 96 months, Outcome 1 Maternal and child health outcomes.

Summary of findings for the main comparison. Welfare to work for lone parents. Maternal health outcomes

Welfare to work for lone parents. Maternal health outcomes

Summaries of all health outcomes reported in the review are provided in Web appendix 1.

Patient or population: lone parents
Settings: high income countries
Intervention: welfare to work

Outcomes

Illustrative comparative risks* (95% CI)

Relative effect
(95% CI)

No of participants
(studies)

Quality of the evidence
(GRADE)

Comments

Assumed risk

Corresponding risk

Control

Welfare to work

T1 maternal mental health
CES‐D (mean score)a

The mean T1 maternal mental health in the intervention groups was
0.07 standard deviations higher
(0.00 to 0.14 higher)

3352
(2 studies)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb

Very small negative effect

T2 maternal mental health
CES‐D (mean score)a

The mean T2 maternal mental health in the intervention groups was
0.00 standard deviations higher
(0.05 lower to 0.05 higher)

7091
(3 studies)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb

No effect

T3 maternal mental health
CES‐D (mean score)a

The mean T3 maternal mental health in the intervention groups was
0.07 standard deviations lower
(0.15 lower to 0 higher)

8873
(4 studies)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb,c

Very small positive effect

T1 maternal self‐rated health
% in poor health. Event defined as poor health

201 per 1000

171 per 1000
(109 to 274)

RR 0.85
(0.54 to 1.36)

311
(1 study)

⊕⊝⊝⊝
Lowb,d

Very small positive effect

T2 maternal self‐rated health
% in good or excellent health. Event defined as good/excellent health

347 per 1000

367 per 1000
(329 to 409)

RR 1.06
(0.95 to 1.18)

2551
(2 studies)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb

Very small positive effect

T3 maternal self‐rated health
% in good or very good health. Event defined as good/excellent health

664 per 1000

645 per 1000
(605 to 691)

RR 0.97
(0.91 to 1.04)

1854
(1 study)

⊕⊕⊝⊝
Lowb,e

Very small negative effect

*The basis for the assumed risk (e.g. the median control group risk across studies) is provided in footnotes. The corresponding risk (and its 95% confidence interval) is based on the assumed risk in the comparison group and the relative effect of the intervention (and its 95% CI).
CI: confidence interval; RR: risk ratio.

Very small effect: unlikely to be substantively important.

Small effect: may be substantively important.

Modest effect: likely to be substantively important.

See Table 5 for further explanation

GRADE Working Group grades of evidence
High quality: further research is very unlikely to change our confidence in the estimate of effect.
Moderate quality: further research is likely to have an important impact on our confidence in the estimate of effect and may change the estimate.
Low quality: further research is very likely to have an important impact on our confidence in the estimate of effect and is likely to change the estimate.
Very low quality: we are very uncertain about the estimate.

a Better indicated by lower values.
b All studies were downgraded due to high risk of bias in at least one domain.
c Heterogeneity over 50% and no plausible explanation identified.
d Confidence interval crosses line of no effect and includes appreciable benefit or harm.
e UK ERA was at very high risk of bias due to high levels of attrition amongst most deprived groups.

Figuras y tablas -
Summary of findings for the main comparison. Welfare to work for lone parents. Maternal health outcomes
Summary of findings 2. Welfare to work for lone parents. Child health outcomes

Welfare to work for lone parents. Child health outcomes

Summaries of all outcomes reported in the review are provided in Web appendix 2

Patient or population: lone parents
Settings: high‐income countries
Intervention: welfare to work

Outcomes

Illustrative comparative risks* (95% CI)

Relative effect
(95% CI)

No of participants
(studies)

Quality of the evidence
(GRADE)

Comments

Assumed risk

Corresponding risk

Control

Welfare to work

T1 child mental health
Behavioural Problems Index (mean score)a

The mean T1 child mental health in the intervention groups was
0.01 standard deviations higher
(0.06 lower to 0.09 higher)

2762
(1 study)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb

Very small negative effect

T2 child mental health
Behavior Problems Index, Behavior Problems Scale, Survey Diagnostic Instrument Conduct Disorder (mean score)a

The mean T2 child mental health in the intervention groups was
0.04 standard deviations lower
(0.08 lower to 0.01 higher)

7560
(5 studies)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb

Very small positive effect

T3 child mental health
Behaviour Problems Index, Behaviour Problems Scale, Problem Behaviour Scale (mean score)a

The mean T3 child mental health in the intervention groups was
0.05 standard deviations lower
(0.16 lower to 0.05 higher)

3643
(3 studies)

⊕⊕⊝⊝
Lowb,c

Very small positive effect

T1 child health (mother reported)
5‐point scale (mean score)d

The mean T1 child health (mother reported) in the intervention groups was
0.05 standard deviations lower
(0.12 lower to 0.03 higher)

2762
(1 study)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb

Very small negative effect

T2 child health (mother reported)
5 point scale, 4 item instrument (mean score)d

The mean T2 child health (mother reported) in the intervention groups was
0.07 standard deviations higher
(0.01 to 0.12 higher)

7195
(3 studies)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb

Very small positive effect

T3 child health (mother reported)
5 point scale, 4 item instrument (mean score)d

The mean T3 child health (mother reported) in the intervention groups was
0.01 standard deviations lower
(0.04 lower to 0.06 higher)

8083
(5 studies)

⊕⊕⊕⊝
Moderateb

Very small positive effect

*The basis for the assumed risk (e.g. the median control group risk across studies) is provided in footnotes. The corresponding risk (and its 95% confidence interval) is based on the assumed risk in the comparison group and the relative effect of the intervention (and its 95% CI).
CI: Confidence interval

Very small effect: unlikely to be substantively important.

Small effect: may be substantively important.

Modest effect: likely to be substantively important.

See Table 5 for further explanation

GRADE Working Group grades of evidence
High quality: Further research is very unlikely to change our confidence in the estimate of effect.
Moderate quality: Further research is likely to have an important impact on our confidence in the estimate of effect and may change the estimate.
Low quality: Further research is very likely to have an important impact on our confidence in the estimate of effect and is likely to change the estimate.
Very low quality: We are very uncertain about the estimate.

a Better indicated by lower values.
b All studies were downgraded due to high risk of bias in at least one domain.
c Heterogeneity over 50% and no plausible explanation identified.
d Better indicated by higher values.

Figuras y tablas -
Summary of findings 2. Welfare to work for lone parents. Child health outcomes
Table 1. Primary outcome measures

Primary outcomes

Reported measures

Parentalmental health

Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES‐D), Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI), University of Michigan Composite International Diagnostic Interview (UM‐CIDI). Currently unhappy, sad or depressed 'very often' or 'fairly often'. Miserable or depressed 'often' or 'always'

Parentalphysical health

5‐item self‐report health measures; ≥ 1 physical health problem(s)

Child mental health

Behavior Problems Index (BPI), Problem Behavior Scale of the Social Skills Rating System (PBS), the Survey Diagnostic Instrument of the Ontario Child Health Survey (SDI), Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), Behavior Problems Scale

Child physical health

5‐item measures of parent reported health, except for the Self‐Sufficiency Project for Applicants (SSP Applicants 2003) and for Recipients (SSP Recipients 2002), which used a 4‐item measure with answers given on a 5‐point scale and averaged across the 5 items.

Figuras y tablas -
Table 1. Primary outcome measures
Table 2. Data extracted in standardised data extraction form

Intervention

 

Bodies initiating and evaluating intervention

Hypothesis for mechanisms linking intervention to health

Location

Dates

Political and economic context

Intervention (and co‐intervention if applicable) approach (i.e. HCD/LFA, anti‐poverty/caseload reduction)

Intervention (and co‐intervention if applicable) components

Other implementation or contextual information

Population

 

Sample demographics (family composition, age, ethnicity)

Socioeconomic factors (employment status)

Sample size

Study information

 

Study duration

Length of follow‐up

Attrition and non‐response

Final sample size

Method of adjusting for confounders

Statistical tests used

Study limitations

Outcomes

 

Outcome measures used

Data collection times

Results

 

Impacts on outcomes at each follow‐up (including all data on statistical tests)

Impacts on relevant subgroups

Other information

 

Authors' orientation

Authors' conclusions

Policy and research recommendations

Reviewers' comments

Figuras y tablas -
Table 2. Data extracted in standardised data extraction form
Table 3. Data collection time points

Time point

T1: 18‐24 months

T2: 25‐48 months

T3 49‐72 months

Narrative synthesis

Study

18 months

24 months

36 months

48 months

54 months

60 months

72 months

96 months

15‐17 years

CJF 2002

X

X

CJF GUP 2000

X

X

CJF Yale 2001

X

FTP 2000

X

X

California GAIN 1994

X

IFIP 2002

X

IWRE 2002

X

MFIP 2000

X

New Hope 1999

X

X

X

NEWWS 2001

X

X

Ontario 2001

X

X

SSP Applicants 2003

X

SSP Recipients 2002

X

X

UK ERA 2011

X

Studies (k)

k = 5

k = 6

k = 7

k = 1

k = 2

Figuras y tablas -
Table 3. Data collection time points
Table 4. Reported subgroups

Study

Type of subgroup

Subgroup

IFIP 2002

Welfare receipt status

Ongoing/applicant

MFIP 2000

Location

Urban/rural

MFIP 2000

Welfare receipt status

Long‐term/recent

MFIP 2000

Intervention

Full intervention/incentives only

NEWWS 2001

Intervention

LFA/HCD

NEWWS 2001

Location

Grand Rapids, Riverside, Atlanta

New Hope 1999

Child age

T1 3‐5 years, 6‐8 years, 9‐12 years

Ontario 2001

Intervention

Full intervention/employment training only

SSP Applicants 2003

Child age

6‐8 years, 9‐14 years

SSP Recipients 2002

Child age

T2: 3‐5 years, 6‐11 years, 12‐18 years; T3: 5.5‐7.5 years, 7.5‐9.5 years

Figuras y tablas -
Table 4. Reported subgroups
Table 5. Definitions of effect magnitude

Cohen's standards

SMD

Odds ratio

Modified approach

SMD

RR

Trivial

< 0.20

< 1.50

Very small

< 0.10

1.01‐1.19

Small

0.20‐0.49

1.50‐2.49

Small

0.10‐0.20

1.20‐1.50

Medium

0.50‐0.79

2.50‐4.29

Modest

> 0.20

> 1.50

Figuras y tablas -
Table 5. Definitions of effect magnitude
Comparison 1. Time point 1 Maternal mental health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Maternal mental health continuous Show forest plot

2

3352

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.07 [0.00, 0.14]

1.1 CES‐D mean score (0‐60)

1

590

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.0 [‐0.16, 0.16]

1.2 CES‐D mean score (0‐36)

1

2762

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.08 [0.01, 0.16]

2 Maternal mental health dichotomous Show forest plot

3

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

2.1 Presence of mood disorders (University of Michigan, Composite International Diagnostic Interview) (%)

1

148

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.99 [0.50, 1.99]

2.2 CES‐D at risk (% ≥ 16/60)

1

311

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.18 [0.80, 1.74]

2.3 CIDI at risk (% threshold not reported)

1

308

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.21 [0.72, 2.06]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 1. Time point 1 Maternal mental health
Comparison 2. Time point 2 Maternal mental health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Maternal mental health continuous Show forest plot

3

7091

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.00 [‐0.05, 0.05]

1.1 CES‐D mean score (0‐60)

2

2576

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.02 [‐0.06, 0.09]

1.2 CES‐D mean score (0‐33)

1

4515

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.01 [‐0.07, 0.05]

2 CJF GUP CES‐D mean score (0‐60) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

3 Maternal mental health dichotomous Show forest plot

2

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

3.1 Unhappy, sad or depressed very often or fairly often (%)

1

2242

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.06 [0.95, 1.18]

3.2 CES‐D at high risk (% ≥ 23/60)

1

1900

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.00 [0.85, 1.18]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 2. Time point 2 Maternal mental health
Comparison 3. Time point 3 Maternal mental health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Maternal mental health continuous Show forest plot

4

8904

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.07 [‐0.15, 0.00]

1.1 CES‐D mean score (0‐60)

2

2232

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.10 [‐0.18, ‐0.01]

1.2 CES‐D mean score (0‐33)

2

6672

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.06 [‐0.18, 0.06]

2 Maternal mental health dichotomous Show forest plot

2

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

2.1 CES‐D at high risk (% ≥ 23/60)

1

1475

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.94 [0.73, 1.20]

2.2 Miserable or depressed often or always (%)

1

1365

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.25 [0.98, 1.59]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 3. Time point 3 Maternal mental health
Comparison 4. Time point 1 Maternal physical health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 In poor health (%) Show forest plot

1

311

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.85 [0.54, 1.36]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 4. Time point 1 Maternal physical health
Comparison 5. Time point 2 Maternal physical health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 In good or excellent health (%) Show forest plot

2

2551

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.06 [0.95, 1.18]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 5. Time point 2 Maternal physical health
Comparison 6. Time point 3 Maternal physical health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Self‐reported health (1‐5) Show forest plot

1

553

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.16 [‐0.01, 0.33]

2 In good or very good health (%) Show forest plot

1

1854

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.97 [0.91, 1.04]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 6. Time point 3 Maternal physical health
Comparison 7. Time point 1 Child mental health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Child behaviour problems continuous Show forest plot

2

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

1.1 Problem Behavior Scale (1‐5)

1

563

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.17 [‐0.34, ‐0.01]

1.2 Behavior Problems Index (0‐2)

1

2762

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.01 [‐0.06, 0.09]

2 Child behaviour problems dichotomous Show forest plot

2

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

2.1 One or more behavior disorders (Survey Diagnostic Instrument) (%)

1

178

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.58 [0.48, 5.24]

2.2 Behavior Problems Index (% with problems)

1

311

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.58 [0.92, 2.72]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 7. Time point 1 Child mental health
Comparison 8. Time point 2 Child mental health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Child behaviour problems continuous Show forest plot

5

7560

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.04 [‐0.08, 0.01]

1.1 Behavioral Problems Index (0‐56)

3

4107

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.05 [‐0.12, 0.01]

1.2 Behavior Problems Scale (1‐3)

1

3201

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.03 [‐0.10, 0.04]

1.3 Survey Diagnostic Instrument Conduct Disorder (0‐30)

1

252

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.06 [‐0.21, 0.32]

2 Adolescent mental health dichotomous Show forest plot

1

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

2.1 Adolescent CES‐D at risk (% ≥ 8/30)

1

1417

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.97 [0.87, 1.08]

3 Child Behavior Checklist (1‐3) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 8. Time point 2 Child mental health
Comparison 9. Time point 3 Child mental health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Child behaviour problems continuous Show forest plot

3

3643

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.05 [‐0.16, 0.05]

1.1 Behavior Problems Scale (1‐3)

1

1134

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.04 [‐0.07, 0.16]

1.2 Behavioral Problems Index (0‐56)

1

1679

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.07 [‐0.16, 0.03]

1.3 Problem Behavior Scale (1‐5)

1

830

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.15 [‐0.29, ‐0.02]

2 Child behaviour problem continuous excluding SSP Applicants Show forest plot

2

2509

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.10 [‐0.18, ‐0.01]

2.1 Behavioral Problems Index (0‐56)

1

1679

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.07 [‐0.16, 0.03]

2.2 Problem behavior scale (1‐5)

1

830

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.15 [‐0.29, ‐0.02]

3 NEWWS 2001 Child mental health Show forest plot

1

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

3.1 BPI Externalising subscore (0‐18)

1

2124

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.12 [‐0.21, ‐0.03]

3.2 BPI Internalising subscore (0‐24)

1

2124

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.04 [‐0.13, 0.04]

3.3 BPI Hyperactivity subscore (0‐18)

1

2124

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.03 [‐0.06, 0.12]

4 IFIP Behavioral Problems Index (0‐56) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

5 SSP‐R T3 Behavior Problems Scale (1‐3) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 9. Time point 3 Child mental health
Comparison 10. Time point 1 Child physical health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 General health rating (1‐5) Show forest plot

1

2762

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.05 [‐0.12, 0.03]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 10. Time point 1 Child physical health
Comparison 11. Time point 2 Child physical health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Child physical health continuous Show forest plot

3

7195

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.07 [0.01, 0.12]

1.1 General health scale (1‐5)

2

2577

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.11 [0.03, 0.19]

1.2 Child average health scale (1‐5 across 4‐item instrument)

1

4618

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.03 [‐0.03, 0.09]

2 Child physical health dichotomous Show forest plot

1

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

2.1 In good or excellent health

1

1900

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.98 [0.93, 1.02]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 11. Time point 2 Child physical health
Comparison 12. Time point 3 Child physical health

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Child physical health continuous Show forest plot

5

8083

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.01 [‐0.04, 0.06]

1.1 Health status scale (1‐5)

1

1679

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.0 [‐0.10, 0.10]

1.2 Overall health scale (1‐5)

1

850

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.09 [‐0.04, 0.23]

1.3 General health rating (1‐5)

1

2124

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.07 [‐0.15, 0.02]

1.4 Child average health scale (1‐5 across 4‐item instrument)

2

3430

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.04 [‐0.03, 0.10]

2 Child physical health dichotomous Show forest plot

1

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

2.1 In fair or poor health (%)

1

1475

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.26 [0.73, 2.14]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 12. Time point 3 Child physical health
Comparison 13. Time point 1 Employment status

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Currently employed (%) Show forest plot

3

3381

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.22 [1.12, 1.32]

2 Ever employed (%) Show forest plot

3

3818

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.14 [1.07, 1.21]

2.1 Ever employed since randomisation (18 months) (%)

1

311

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.17 [1.03, 1.34]

2.2 Ever employed year 2 (%)

1

745

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.09 [1.03, 1.15]

2.3 Ever employed since randomisation (24 months) (%)

1

2762

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.17 [1.11, 1.24]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 13. Time point 1 Employment status
Comparison 14. Time point 2 Employment status

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Ever employed (%) Show forest plot

5

12274

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.13 [1.08, 1.19]

1.1 Ever employed since randomisation (36 months)

2

4845

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.14 [1.03, 1.26]

1.2 Average employment year of study

2

2577

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.10 [1.03, 1.17]

1.3 Employed at 33 months

1

4852

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.19 [1.10, 1.28]

2 Ever employed full‐time since randomisation (%) Show forest plot

3

9806

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.20 [1.05, 1.37]

3 Ever employed full‐time excluding MFIP (%) Show forest plot

2

8275

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.29 [1.18, 1.40]

4 Employed part‐time (%) Show forest plot

3

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

4.1 Ever employed part‐time since randomisation

2

4845

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.14 [1.04, 1.25]

4.2 Currently employed part‐time

1

4852

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.80 [0.69, 0.93]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 14. Time point 2 Employment status
Comparison 15. Time point 3 Employment status

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Currently employed (%) Show forest plot

6

14355

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.03 [0.99, 1.07]

2 Ever employed (%) Show forest plot

3

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

2.1 Ever employed year 5

2

2599

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.01 [0.96, 1.06]

2.2 Ever employed years 1‐5

1

2124

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.12 [1.08, 1.17]

3 Currently employed full‐time (%) Show forest plot

6

13233

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.05 [1.00, 1.12]

4 Currently employed part‐time (%) Show forest plot

5

12676

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.93 [0.85, 1.01]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 15. Time point 3 Employment status
Comparison 16. Time point 1 Income

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Total income Show forest plot

2

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

1.1 Total income year 2 (USD)

1

744

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.11 [‐0.04, 0.25]

1.2 Total net household income in prior month (USD)

1

2762

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.08 [‐0.15, ‐0.00]

2 Earnings Show forest plot

1

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

2.1 Average annual earnings year 2 (USD)

1

744

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.07 [‐0.08, 0.21]

3 NEWWS T1 Average earnings previous month (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 16. Time point 1 Income
Comparison 17. Time point 2 Income

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Total income Show forest plot

4

8934

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.10 [0.02, 0.17]

1.1 Average annual income (benefits, earnings and food stamps) years 3‐4 (USD)

1

1469

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.01 [‐0.11, 0.09]

1.2 Average total income (benefits, earnings and food stamps) year 4 (USD)

1

1108

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.08 [‐0.04, 0.20]

1.3 Average annual income (benefits and earnings) year 3 (USD) 

1

1531

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.14 [0.03, 0.24]

1.4 Total monthly individual income (average from all sources in 6 months prior to 3‐year survey) (CAD)

1

4826

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.15 [0.10, 0.21]

2 Total income excluding CJF Show forest plot

3

7465

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.14 [0.09, 0.18]

2.1 Average total income from earnings, AFDC/TANF and food stamps year 4 (USD)

1

1108

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.08 [‐0.04, 0.20]

2.2 Average annual income welfare/earnings year 3 (USD) 

1

1531

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.14 [0.03, 0.24]

2.3 Total monthly individual income 6 months prior to 3‐year survey (CAD)

1

4826

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.15 [0.10, 0.21]

3 Average earnings in year of survey (USD) Show forest plot

2

6321

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.09 [0.04, 0.13]

4 MFIP Average annual earnings years 1‐3 (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

5 GAIN Average weekly earnings since randomisation (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

6 FTP Average earnings in year of study (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 17. Time point 2 Income
Comparison 18. Time point 3 Income

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Total income Show forest plot

5

11745

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.01 [‐0.04, 0.06]

1.1 Total household income month prior to survey, annualised (USD)

1

1679

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.03 [‐0.13, 0.06]

1.2 Total income year 5 (USD)

1

745

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.06 [‐0.09, 0.20]

1.3 Total income years 1‐5 (USD)

1

2124

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.05 [‐0.04, 0.14]

1.4 Total monthly individual income at 72 months (CAD)

1

2371

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.07 [‐0.01, 0.15]

1.5 Total monthly individual income (average in 6 months prior to month 54 (CAD)

1

4826

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.04 [‐0.09, 0.02]

2 IFIP household income month prior to survey (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

3 Total earnings Show forest plot

5

11501

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.04 [‐0.00, 0.07]

3.1 Average earnings year 5 (USD)

1

745

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.05 [‐0.09, 0.20]

3.2 Average earnings year 6 (CAD)

1

2371

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.08 [0.00, 0.16]

3.3 Average earnings year 5 (GBP)

1

1854

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.06 [‐0.04, 0.15]

3.4 Earnings month prior to survey, annualised (USD)

1

1679

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.01 [‐0.09, 0.11]

3.5 Monthly earnings year 5, quarter 18 (CAD)

1

4852

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.01 [‐0.05, 0.07]

4 IFIP Average earnings month prior to survey (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

5 NEWWS T3 Average earnings years 1‐5 (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 18. Time point 3 Income
Comparison 19. Time point 1 Welfare receipt

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Total AFDC received year 2 (USD) Show forest plot

1

744

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.10 [‐0.24, 0.04]

2 Proportion of sample receiving welfare (%) Show forest plot

3

3714

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.88 [0.84, 0.92]

2.1 Received social assistance in last 12 months

1

207

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.85 [0.76, 0.97]

2.2 Currently receiving AFDC

1

2762

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.87 [0.83, 0.92]

2.3 Ever received AFDC/TANF year 2

1

745

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.94 [0.84, 1.06]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 19. Time point 1 Welfare receipt
Comparison 20. Time point 2 Welfare receipt

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Average annual welfare benefit Show forest plot

4

8960

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.11 [‐0.36, 0.15]

1.1 Average annual welfare benefit year 3 (USD)

1

1469

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.22 [‐0.32, ‐0.11]

1.2 Average Income Assistance year 3 (CAD)

1

4852

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.18 [‐0.24, ‐0.13]

1.3 Average annual welfare benefit year 3 (USD) 

1

1531

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.33 [0.22, 0.43]

1.4 Total AFDC/TANF received year 4 (USD)

1

1108

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.35 [‐0.47, ‐0.23]

2 Average annual welfare benefit excluding MFIP Show forest plot

3

7429

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.24 [‐0.33, ‐0.15]

2.1 Average annual welfare benefit year 3 (USD)

1

1469

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.22 [‐0.32, ‐0.11]

2.2 Total AFDC/TANF received year 4 (USD)

1

1108

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.35 [‐0.47, ‐0.23]

2.3 Average Income Assistance year 3 (USD/CAD)

1

4852

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.18 [‐0.24, ‐0.13]

3 Proportion of sample receiving welfare Show forest plot

2

5210

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.87 [0.83, 0.91]

3.1 Social assistance/unemployment insurance receipt year 4 (%)

1

358

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.90 [0.71, 1.14]

3.2 Income Assistance receipt year 3 (%)

1

4852

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.87 [0.83, 0.90]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 20. Time point 2 Welfare receipt
Comparison 21. Time point 3 Welfare receipt

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Total welfare benefit received Show forest plot

4

9822

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.06 [‐0.11, ‐0.00]

1.1 Total AFDC/TANF receipt year 5 (USD)

1

745

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.01 [‐0.14, 0.15]

1.2 Average Income Assistance received year 6 (CAD)

1

2371

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.12 [‐0.20, ‐0.04]

1.3 Average Income Support received per wk (GBP)

1

1854

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

0.0 [‐0.09, 0.09]

1.4 Average Income Assistance received year 5 (CAD)

1

4852

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.07 [‐0.12, ‐0.01]

2 Total welfare payments years 1‐5 (USD) Show forest plot

1

2124

Std. Mean Difference (IV, Random, 95% CI)

‐0.55 [‐0.63, ‐0.46]

3 IWRE TANF receipt month before survey, annualised year 5 (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

4 IFIP Average welfare received month prior to survey (USD) Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

5 Proportion of sample receiving welfare Show forest plot

6

12976

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.92 [0.86, 0.99]

5.1 Currently receiving TANF (%)

1

1679

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.79 [0.67, 0.93]

5.2 Ever received AFDC/TANF year 5 (%)

1

745

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.91 [0.64, 1.29]

5.3 Currently receiving Income Support or Jobseeker's Allowance (%)

1

1854

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.98 [0.87, 1.11]

5.4 Currently receiving Family Independence Payment (%)

1

1475

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.09 [0.89, 1.33]

5.5 Currently receiving Income Assistance (%)

1

2371

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.84 [0.72, 0.98]

5.6 Currently receiving Income Assistance (%)

1

4852

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.94 [0.89, 0.99]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 21. Time point 3 Welfare receipt
Comparison 22. Time point 1 Health insurance

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Respondent has health insurance (%) Show forest plot

4

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

1.1 Respondent has Medicaid

2

606

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.16 [1.08, 1.25]

1.2 Respondent had any health insurance since randomisation (24 months)

1

590

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.09 [1.03, 1.16]

1.3 Respondent ever had employer‐provided health insurance since randomisation (24 months)

1

2762

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.40 [1.16, 1.69]

2 Child health insurance (%) Show forest plot

1

2762

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.99 [0.96, 1.01]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 22. Time point 1 Health insurance
Comparison 23. Time point 2 Health insurance

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Health insurance (%) Show forest plot

2

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

1.1 Respondent has Medicaid or other health insurance within 2‐3 years of randomisation

1

2193

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.97 [0.93, 1.01]

1.2 Children have continuous health insurance for past 36 months

1

1531

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

1.16 [1.08, 1.24]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 23. Time point 2 Health insurance
Comparison 24. Time point 3 Health insurance

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Health insurance Show forest plot

3

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

Subtotals only

1.1 Family has health insurance (%)

2

3599

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.98 [0.92, 1.05]

1.2 Respondent has health insurance (%)

1

561

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.97 [0.91, 1.04]

1.3 All focal children have health insurance (%)

1

561

Risk Ratio (M‐H, Random, 95% CI)

0.95 [0.89, 1.02]

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 24. Time point 3 Health insurance
Comparison 25. New Hope 96 months

Outcome or subgroup title

No. of studies

No. of participants

Statistical method

Effect size

1 Maternal and child health outcomes Show forest plot

Other data

No numeric data

Figuras y tablas -
Comparison 25. New Hope 96 months